Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

WW II - Why didn't we drop the Bomb on Tokyo?
Find answers to your legal question.





WW II - Why didn't we drop the Bomb on Tokyo?

This may be a dumb question and if I'm ignorant, please forgive me but...

Why didn't we drop the A-Bomb on Tokyo? It would seem to me that since that was their biggest city, their capital, the centralized headquarters for everything, that this would be the place to bomb and send a bigger message. What was in Nagasaki and Hiroshima that was was more important than Tokyo?

Thanks for your replies.


    




knh959
Because there were a large number of allied POWs in and around Tokyo. Also, probably because athe US didn't want to completely destroy the government. They needed somebody who was still alive to surrender.


agent of chaos
Rating
The people we needed to agree to the surrender were there, if we had killed the Royal family they may have never given up.


don c
There wouldn't have been any decision makers left to surrender


donall520
Undamaged targets were chosen to accurately assess the damage these new weapons would cause.

These targets were also hubs in manufacturing war materiel.


desertviking_00
Rating
Tokyo had been utterly destroyed by a massive bombing campaign carried out under the command of Nate Twining. The number of dead and injured in the entire Kanto Plain from that bombing exceeded the totals for Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Hiroshima was a major Naval base and industrial center. Nagasaki was an important industrial center.


ducky
charlie is right

Doolittle "fire bombed" Tokyo
that raid killed more people than either Atomic Bomb did.
The entire city was set ablaze
it was unbelievably horrific
---------------
oops - It was NOT Doolittle
sorry, my bad !


Bye for now...
Rating
I think we probably had in mind the fact that, as Colin Powell said about Iraq "Once you break it, you own it".

We were going to be the ones to come in and sweep up the pieces, so the decision was made that Tokyo would be one of the pieces left intact.


charlie
because it was already destroyed be doolittle
he drooped a whole bunch of bombs from planes and it was destroyed so we couldnt destroy it any more


Alan S
It was foggy over Tokyo that day so they went to target #2. Hey, I'm sorry if you don't like the answer but that's the reason, they didn't have a good visual so they moved on to the next default target. It's history.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 When did you join the US military and what is your rank now?
thank ...


 Does anyone else feel that congress should say out of war business?
“Democrats reject general's Iraq plan”
Does this headline make anyone else upset? I should first say I am a democrat . But it is my view that if we go to war we shouldn’t tie out men’s arms ...


 What is your opinion on the fact that people today aren't as interested in fighting for their country?
it is hard for armies today to even find people to join, no one wants to be put in the middle of todays battles!!...


 Will China take over the United States?
With China's growing economy, military might and partnership with Russia, how long will it be before the chinese come over to invade America? Will Russia join in on the invasion?...


 I'm a pretty big guy, can I join the military?
I'm 19 years old, 6'0 and 270 lbs. I also had asthma when I was younger but it seems to have gone away. I also have not graduated high school, but I am about to get my GED.

I'...


 Why is President Bush failing in the Middle East?
Failed Baghdad security plan forces US rethink by Paul Schemm


BAGHDAD (AFP) - American forces were seeking new ways to stem the slaughter in Baghdad after previous tactics failed to ...


 Do you lie to your children and tell them Santa Claus exist?
This question is for the righteous right, the doctor Phil wanna be.Do you lie to your children and tell them Santa Claus exist? I think its a bad practice reaaly..

Most people tell their K...


 Im thinking about joining the marines..any advice?
...


 Why is the AK-47 famous?
I have seen AK-47s in games, TVs, etc. What makes the AK-47 famous? Is it better than the M16A2/M4A1?...


 What do you think they REALLY have at Area 51?
A recent tabloid article stated that it was a time machine rather than anything relating to extraterrestrial life....


 If all the Flag-draped coffins of killed GI's in Iraqwere together, how many football fields would they cover?

Additional Details
I did not realize that I needed to be "protected" from Iraq. Were they about to launch an invasion of Atlantic City or something?...


 How can people think that killing more people will bring peace?

Additional Details
geoweeg - by saying 'defeat' in place of killing is like saying "destroy" the bear not "kill".

Who are the "they" ...


 How come no College students demonstrate against the war in Iraq like they did back in the 60s and 70s (Vietna
Young men and women being killed everyday so where is the outrage?...


 What is the best workout to do to prepare for basic training for the military?
im not the exercising type... but i can follow a workout. im 17, 5'11" and weight 139lbs ... im pretty sure i have about 6-7 mouths b4 navy bootcamp....so id like to know what kind of diet ...


 Lets get together in the name of world peace..?
The world is burning in the blazes of war.. Humans attack each other with dangerous weapons killing hundreds of thousands of fellow beings not realising the value of LIFE. No matter what race. ...


 A question for Military personel....?
My husband is Army and decided to re-enlist, we were out with a friend who is civilian and he asked us this question...
"Although I understand the serving your country, Why do you CHOOSE to ...


 Should Bush & Cheney & other top Bush Administration officials be charged with war crimes for the war in Iraq?

Additional Details
and be put on trial then summarily executed for the falsed led invasion that has killed and maimed hundreds of thousands of innocents?...


 Should i stay with my boyfriend since hes joining the military?
ive been with friends with my current boyfriend for over two years. last months we decided to give a relationship a try.its working out great. i think i could really fall in love with him. the only ...


 Is there such a thing as supporting our troops AND be against the war at the same time?
...


 England to get their soldiers back! (THANKFULLY) Do you think they MAY have been in Iran's waters?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034