Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

What do I say to a young child who asks, "Do solders kill people?"?
Find answers to your legal question.





What do I say to a young child who asks, "Do solders kill people?"?



    




Zorki K
Look at your child and say they do whatever it takes to protect you and me.


§♥Elisabeth♥§
Rating
Well...don't lie to them....say they do what they have to, to protect themselves and their country


Kenya C
"No, bullets do."


edward m
Rating
They protect you and me from bad people


Ryu
Rating
Tell them the truth. They kill to protect.


lauren r
Rating
yes, but for a good reason


Mark C
Rating
tell them the truth...it's war


LeAnnderthal
they defend our lives, so that lots of people dont get killed


Jeremy R
Rating
Tell them that sometimes it is necessary to kill people in order to protect other people.


brouz
if you want to be the best parent, best example you can be, then you would not lie to them. You would give them only the information you know they can handle.

If they are old enough to ask the question, then they are old enough to hear the answer.

However, only you know the age and maturity level of your child and you can decide how much to expand on/ or how to phrase the answer so as not to disturb their mind beyond what they can handle.

You may say "War is a hard subject. Maybe when you are older, we can talk about it more. But, yes, sometimes people do die as the resault of war"


ricesoul
u tell the truth...cuz they will prolly know ur lying if u tell them that soldiers dont kill pple...or they will find out later anyway


Alex
Rating
That reminds me of the quote from an unknown sniper. Asked, "What do you feel when you kill a person?", the response back was, "A slight recoil."


csigeoffrey
Rating
The Marines have said that we don't kill people, we just make sure that they meet God according to our appointment book.


eddie9551
"Some times they do, but soldiers keep people safe from the bad guys and sometimes they have to (kill the bad guys)"


tabby
Rating
Explain that soldiers protect our country from bad people, and yes, sometimes the bad people die, but only because our soldiers care about us so much that they would do anything to protect us.


where is everybody?
not all soldiers kill people. soldiers are like the police. they kill to protect others and have safety for all


italienne
Rating
War is a terrible thing and people die in a war. No one wants to kill in a war but sometimes you have to or you will be killed.


pbsCB21
Rating
just let your child know that they do, but they kill bad people that want to hurt you.


na$ty
Rating
hell yeah we kill people. but only because they try to kill us. we're just better at it. jadji is stupid.


doughnut
Rating
You say that soldiers do everything possible to prevent the loss of life, but sometimes soldiers have to protect themselves and their fellow soldiers from people that wish to hurt them and sometimes they have to make these people die for their country or cause in order to ensure the safety their buddies or themselves.


I ♥ my Irishman!
I'd tell them yes...but only the bad people that want to hurt the good people. tell the child that its a soldiers job to find the bad people that want to hurt the good people before they do hurt them.


As the army of Helaman
Rating
u could say yes


cheyenne
You tell them the truth. Then they understand about what goes on and realize that sometimes during war that they have a job to do and that they have to defend themselves when put in those positions. You can't sugar coat reality, and there's no point in doing so.


Nick K
Tell the child that they only don't kill, however they defend... They defend your right to write what you want... They defend your right to eat out with your family.... They defend your right to life, sometimes losing their own being so selfless as to defend everyone that they care about..... They defend your right to ask your mother or teacher such questions, they defend your right to expand your imagination, your right to learn... Only two people have died so that others may live in freedom, Jesus and Soldiers.........


DOOM
Yes. It's what we're here for. I refuse to die so that my enemy may live.


presidentofallantarctica
Rating
Say, "A soldier fights to win wars and make peace. They're not trying to kill people, but in war it does happen; war is dangerous, it's unfortunate. And most soldiers don't fight with guns, some are mechanics, or secretaries, or drivers, people who support the military effort." etc, etc. Of course, this doesn't apply to an army sniper, but there's no need to go into such detail yet. The fact is, most members of the military don't actually kill people.


justsomegirl
No they kill terrorist's n' thier family's so we can sleep at night.


13DoMiNiC31
Rating
Say yes but also say that the are doing it because they want to stop bad people from hurting you and your family.


Delta tac Juliet tac
Rating
There is an extreame difference between killing and murduring. You need to explain this first.


Jade Rat
Rating
"Soldiers protect you, they fight the bad guys"

You try to protect the kid until he/she is old enough to understand it- how old is he/she? When i was about 6 i already knew the difference between murder and killing to protect- but then again i was always uniquely insightful about things i really wasn't expected to understand. I always remembered my dad telling me how amazed he was about my ability to understand complicated things like war and how its different than murder.

So it may depend on how well the child's able to understand the difference. If you suspect it's to young to comprehend the difference between murder and killing to protect- then try to steer away, by answering the question- but not in the way they asked.

When the child's older, then you should feel free to tell them more and more, but i don't think anyone really has a right to take away a child's innocent mind at such a young age- let them be a kid and enjoy a carefree life for a while- everyone deserves that much really.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Any of you guys want to THANK George Bush and Tony Blair ( and our military) for saving your butts AGAIN?
I do!
Thanks for not worrying about being politically correct and stopping terrorists at the airport instead of blonds.
Thank you CIA and FBI for listening into the calls that the BAD GUYS ...


 Do you think the united states should go to war?
...


 Which one is worse? Clinton screwed a girl and his wife forgave him, Bush screwed the world and our troops die
...


 Why do so many Americans pretend our soldiers aren't murdering innocent civilians?

Additional Details
I didn't say all our soldiers,, I said our soldiers... if they aren't our soldiers, who's are they?...


 Do you support the troops in Iraq?
Are you one of those who support the troops that are fighting for the freedom in Iraq? If you don't, at least explain your reason....


 Is it possible to invade the United States of America?
The answer is clearly NO, but I won't to hear what the disbelievers have to say... An invasion of America would be impossible. Even if the entire world came crashing down on America with a ...


 Why do people clap when soilders arrive at the airport?
I was at JFK the other day, and a plane arrived with a bunch of military guys, and they were all in their uniforms, and everyone started clapping when they walked through the terminal.

WTF...


 Wanted: Some well-wishes for my son in Iraq.?
Our son is a Marine serving in Iraq, and has about a month left. He is horribly home sick and losing his motivation. I'd like to start sending him words of encouragement to help boost his moral. ...


 When will Americans stand up and say "We don't want anymore of our men and women killed in Iraq!"
I say, give George Bush an M-16 and send him to Bagdad.

(and watch how fast the war comes to a close)
Additional Details
And to all you neocons, don't give me that crap ...


 If your son wanted to join the army ...?
would you try and discourage him in view of the current conflict in Iraq and Afghanistan. Would you be prepared for him to be killed whilst serving this country?...


 What does a suicide bomber think in those last few seconds?
Is it maddness, hate, rage or have they been cleverly brainwashed into believing someone else's selfish cause?
I'm in the bussiness of saving lives so I can't comprehend taking ...


 Should bush be impeached?
george bush makes me feel like i could be president that's how poor of a president it think he is and im sorry for those of you who disagree but you have to understand that he has had alot of ...


 Who likes President Bush?
...


 Who would win this battle 10,000 Spartans or 100,000 Marines?
Both have modern weaponery and the Spartans tactics are tweaked for the 21st century. Keep in mind that the Spartans were trained since birth and know no pain or defeat....


 I am contemplating joining the military.?
I'm seventeen and I am thinking about joining the military for no other reason then to serve the country that has done so much for me. However my mother doesn't take me seriously all she ...


 Is it OK to say "I told you so" at a militry funeral for a dead soldier killed in Iraq?
I belong to the American Legion and we are going to a military funeral this Sunday and I want to say to the war supporters "I told you he would die being so Gung Ho". Should I gloat? Should ...


 What time is 20:30 in military time?
10 points guaranteed for best ...


 If Saddam really had WMD's like the Pro-War camp now insists, why didn't Saddam use them against us?
Was it because Saddam was such a nice guy that he would rather lose all his power, his family, and his life than to use his vast stockpiles against those nice invading Americans? Something doesn'...


 Is a Military draft a good idea?
...


 How do you feel about gays in the military?
Please state which country you are from along with your opinion. Americans please address don't ask don't tell. And Brits please respond with your thoughts and perceived public response to ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084