Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

What do you think about this? WARNING!?
Find answers to your legal question.





What do you think about this? WARNING!?

This is not intended to get any anti-war activists going on a rampage. What I am going to relate is a story about a humanbeing that just happens to be a soldier. I just want some opinions. I am currently in the Mid-East my wife works at a Hospital in Texas. I young soldier on Terminal Leave (that is leave time up to his discharge from service) visiting a friend in Texas was rushed to the hospital with a broken arm, the ER orthopedic doctor refused to see or even set this soldiers arm, because the government insurance is not excepted. This soldier has two combat tours in Iraq. These doctors have none. It took my family doctor to call these doctors to the carpet as to what their duties are as doctors. People need to realize these young men and women are in a hostile invironment, the invironment is hostile even with out bombs and bullets. They don't want to be there (but they are) and when they do get to come home they don't need to be treated like second class citizens.
Additional Details
He wasn't asking for royal treatment he wanted his broken arm set!

Texas is a big state and I hope you never break a bone in it and have to drive to find a doctor to set it for you.

The Bush administration has nothing to do with the oath a doctor takes to heal


    




DEATH
Here, here.

As much as I am against the war, I support our soldiers and what they are doing, 110%.

As much as I want them to come home, I don't want to see them treated like scum, because they are anything but!

These brave men and women have signed themselves over as property and have done the job they signed up to do.
I'm afraid to think that these men and women are going to be treated like the soldiers coming home from VietNam. That's just not fair!


onewhoknows
federal law mandates that no one can be turned away due to innabbillity to pay, so even if his insurance was not taken at the hospital he should not have been turned away and could have one hell of a law-suit on the hospital.


ole_lady_93
Rating
Sorry about the Texas Drs. --Sounds like they are related to the W.V. Drs. It goes like this No Money-or Insurance.
You Hain't sick go home!!! While they treated a woman with a stubbed toe-and My 2 yr old was at the emergency room with blood comming out of his ear from an infected ear that ruptured the drum!!!


zclifton2
Universal health care is on the way for everyone. Of course the veteran should be helped.


parshooter
Rating
Welcome to the lie that is the bush administration.


?
Rating
Doctor's are here to take care of anyone in need of medical treatment weather if he/she is insured they can't refuse anyone medical treatment and for that they may loose. Take it to court sue the a holes. They don't take an oath not to attend people uninsured but to take care of anyone of need of medical attention.


The Rebel
Rating
It makes me sick...As a veteran I had the same experience at the VA. It all comes downto the lawmakers in Washington. We elected and sent Idiots to represent us. They party and go on junkets and their staff runs the country. I doubt even one could make a speech that he/she wrote. The end result is "We deserve it". We elected these dummies and sent them there. As long as we send them .... we have to live with their priorities.
End of sermon.

You can vote them out.


Doesnt Matter
Rating
They don't need to be treated like royalty either. I mean yes, it's great that they joined our military, but they don't need to expect everything from everyone they come across. If the insurance is not accepted, then find another doctor. Texas is a big state.


Kooties_ 2000
I think these "so-called" doctors, need to have their licenses suspended. Obviously, they've forgotten the "Hippocratic Oath." "First do no harm." They've actually done harm.


starting over
Rating
I hear you, my son is in the Navy, he probably has a torn meniscus. He has been on crutches for about a month now and and can't get an MRI scheduled until I think he said July 23.

He was told he could come home and have the surgery, this way Mom can take care of him. I have called every orthopedic surgeon within 50 miles and no one will accept the insurance, But we can sign some forms where he will be liable for the difference. Of course, no one seems to be able to come up with a number, so that a reasonably intelligent decision can be made.

Is that thanks or what?


celticgirl27
Rating
not positive but I don't think (by law) that ER docs are allowed to turn anyone away. not saying this didn't happen, just saying he may have violated a law.


buzzzard
Rating
I understand what you're saying, but he didn't get turned away because was a soldier. People get turned away from hospitals everyday because they don't have insurance. And to be fair, the hospitals can't incur the expense of everyone who walks in. That would end up closing down the hospital. Don't get angry at the doctor for following policy, get angry that in this great country of ours (I'm not being sarcastic) we still haven't figured out a way to provide health-care to everyone who needs it.


soulsearcher
Rating
The Army should have better coverage.
The doctors can try to be flexible, but everyone has a story.
They are under the thumb of HMOS
We should all friggin have heathcare in this country---its a total joke!
www.votetoimpeach.org
thats my rampage.


shasha
that makes me sad, because EVERY human being needs to be helped!! What if someone is dying that person needs to be saved its the doctors duties to do so, and it would be inhumane to do that! People need to have a heart. They should send the bill to Bush he sent the soldiers to Iraq!!


JUDY F
Rating
I think your story was an outrage. This guys a serving in the military and defending our country. They should be treated like hero's not no bodies. Those doctors should be reported for there actions.


pootfart3
Rating
I think it is absolutely outrageous for any doctor to refuse to give medical service to anyone. They should follow their Hippocratic Oath and stop being a HIPPOCRIT!!!!!!!!!


BlueAngel
Rating
I'm very sorry. That should NEVER have happened to him or anyone else. :(


Indigo
Rating
I agree. Though I have to say that no person deserves to be treated as a second class citizen, soldier or not. It's all about insurance or the money now, they will screw anyone over no matter who. They will let someone, even a child, die without the right insurance. It is awful. : (


fivebyfivereal
Rating
L3, hate to be hardcore but get used to it. I have been a Veterans' Service Officer, 11 years, VA "accredited representative",( means VA credentialled), 9 years.

VA can't even keep records safe, so if you think this incident was bad, wait until you need the VA.

Why so bad you ask? Vet told me the other day, "they are done with us now". Made sense. I still use every weapon I have to get justice and I am pleasant to start but don't try to screw a Veteran out of what he/she has earned, because I always complete the mission. Took 11 years but the "law is the law", and if VA doesn't follow it, they lose. Just takes forever and a day!

I love my Country and my Country better love my Vets.


Ryan
Rating
That's just sick, i mean these are probably the same people who would offer care to illigal immigrants without question. I can't believe how stupid and idiotic these people are. I think these kind of doctors should be fired just because they don't seem to know about their profession very well. I'm willing to bet these are the kind of people who take Liberals seriously because they don't like soldiers very much either.


elderone2004
Rating
Since the government pays all medical expenses of active duty personnel in emergency situations, there was no question of insurance payment. More than likely these so called doctors were more influenced by their political views. Hopefully, after the lawsuit, this young person will never have to work again.


mrhpotter7
Man, that doctor is honestly stupid in doing that, I totally agree with you, man. That is a sad story, but that's what people do...same thing happened in Vietnam.....discrimination of the soldiers that fought for our freedom.


Renee
I thought it was illegal to not give emergency treatment to someone regardless of insurance. I have Tricare (military insurance) and I have never had any problems with ER's they are all SUPPOSED to take Tricare. Even in Germany I was seen in the ER off base.


Bill S
Rating
Doctors take an oath when they get their licence called this Hipocratic Oath. In that oath they solomly swear to take care of the sick and wounded, no matter what. That is why the doctor that took care of J.W. Boothe took care of him. The doctors involved should be stripped of their licences and never allowed to practice medicine again.
To me it doesn't matter that this young hero was in the service the bottom line is that the doctors violated the Hipocratic Oath. So they should not be doctors any more. I hope your family physician reported them to whatever councils they report these types of scumbags too.
Unfortunately the meidcal field is becoming corporatized they are only in it for the money.


mikis1967
Rating
If it were an illegal alien. No problem.

That (if true) should be put on the news. Call the local news and give them the hospital name and the doctor's name. That should get a ball rolling.

Oh, I forgot, the liberal media wouldn't show it anyway.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do we teach our children to respect human life only to send them off to war at 18?
...


 Who won in Iraq war?
pls don't relpy as iraq or usa
Additional Details
If someone noticed it's who won in iraq war not who won the war in iraq.It' retoric at all senses.Anyway i've chosen ...


 If they'd have kept their eyes shut?
They'd have one that war?

What do you think?...


 What u think of iraqi shoe thrower?

Additional Details
Thanks for sharing all your opinions.
In my humble opinion I really look up to that man Muntazar Al-Zaidi, mostly refered to as the infamous shoe thrower. At ...


 Why does the US have 120,000 nuclear weapons?
...


 Are there Muslim soldiers in the US army?
i mean fighting muslim against another muslims country is a big sin but not listenin to their leaders is a big sin too
i mean if theres a muslim american was born there raised there and happened ...


 I am in the Army Do you think i am dumb and cant read?
http://newsbusters.org/b
i cant read.........another Stephen King book again
A...


 Is the UN Afraid? Why no action against Israel..?
I quote from BBC .....UN peacekeepers in south Lebanon contacted Israeli troops 10 times before an Israeli bomb killed four of them, an initial UN report says.
The post was hit by a precision-...


 My Husband is in the army. He is in basic tranning and he wants out does any one know if he can quite?
...


 What was the best tank of the second world war?
I would say the Russian T34
Additional Details
Actually the tigers in Kellys heros were converted t34s made to look like ...


 Is Iraq worth it?
I say yes.

http://www.timesonline.c...


 Do the Republicans know the Vietnam war was lost under a Republican President?
Source: CNN. President Ford made the Marines and Army run like scared dogs on 30th April 1975. Thanks Republicans....


 Why are we losing so many Americans ( soldiers ) in Iraq in just one day?
Military News:.. U.S. casualties will rise in next 90 days, Commander says.
The U.S. military announced the deaths of 11 U.S. soldiers killed in combat along with an embedded journalist Sunday, ...


 I Could die in the military?
I've been deciding whether or not to join the navy for a long time. I eventually pretty much decided and want to be a Gunner's Mate. I brought up the subject of the military to my mom the ...


 Am I wrong for not thinking this is funny?
I have members of every military branch in my family. when we all get together we usaully laugh at each other, jokingly putting the other branch down. The other day I read an answer to a question in ...


 Whom do you consider to be the greatest American military man (army,navy,air force) in history?

Additional Details
My own choice would be admiral Nimitz, for his perfect naval tactics and victories against equal odds and for the breadth of imagination in his plans....


 What is the longist US war?
...


 Why are people quick to down talk the Military but can't thank a Soldier for their freedom of speech?
I'm tired of these uninformed rejects (Sunsar Taylor & Co.)running their mouths about the Military! Hey sweetheart... you don't stand behind me and my brothers & sisters at arms???...


 Which war claimed the lives of the most US soldiers???
...


 Do you think the Government should bring back National Service to keep the teenage crime figures down?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.114