Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

What do you think of the young army officier who refuses to go to Iraq?
Find answers to your legal question.





What do you think of the young army officier who refuses to go to Iraq?



    




Rasta
Rating
He has a very good point...when he joined he believed just like everyone else did..that there was a threat against the US...And that threat was weapons of mass destruction....now years later he found out that the threat was really OIL...


BlueSea
When you join the military you take an oath to serve, not to serve where YOU want to serve. I think he is a coward. Especially when my daughter was over there fighting and I do mean fighting, she has the combat medals to prove it and she says she would go back again in a heartbeat.


Bark
Rating
he should probably have entered a different career path,
i.e. he's a dumbass


☼.☺ CIEL☺ .☼
Rating
We have an all volunteer military, and he VOLUNTEERED.........he should be court martialed!


dtc_ox
Rating
He should be court marshalled and thrown in the brig. If you do not want to serve your country, don't enlist in the Army and take a free college education.


jizzum100
Rating
he is scum. he had young soldiers depending on him to do his job and he let them down.


ticd
can you say court martial? hes lucky during a time of war
he wasnt shot...


.
Rating
Im thinking he used the military to get what he wanted and now he is renigging on his part of the bargain. He should pay back the government for what they paid to train him.


Strikernow
Rating
He should be court-marshalled and drummed out of the military.
It's not like the day of Vietnam where troops were drafted, he signed up to serve and should have realized that there was a good possibility he might be sent to the middle east.


Darby
I think he made the wrong career choice. When you are in the military, you do what you are ordered to do, period.


Jen
The he shouldn't be in the Army to begin with.


?
Hmm...why did the buffoon join the army in the first place? For speaking out loud, I think he can eat shiit too.


lefty
I think he should be court martialed and given a dishonorable discharge.


vince
Good way to set a leadership example for your troops. You should have stood alongside of Saddam. He ran too.


wei_bei_li
Rating
took the queens shilling, should follow orders


sophieb
when a person signs up for the military they become the "property of" the Army, Navy, Airforce or Marines, etc. and that means they cannot say no to their superiors. When they sign up they also know they will go to war no matter where the war is. When they refuse they can, from what I know, get a dishonorable discharge (difficult to get a job after that), or perhaps be jailed in a military jail and do time. During the Viet Nam war the conscientious objectors fled to Canada. So what do I think of a person who disgraces the military? I'd be wondering why did that person sign up in the first place since the military is no longer a lottery. I'd consider them a deserter. How could you trust them then?


kherome
Rating
Court Martial! Throw him in prison and leave him there. Hope he enjoys the black mark it leaves on his entire life. You don't join the Army, take their money and then refuse to give back as you promised. The love of my life is over there, doing his job! Not being a little weasel here.


minus
If he is an officer then he deliberately became part of the military.
Military is a fighting force and it is most likely going to be involved in a war. He must have known this so if he refuses to go where he is sent then he should be tried tor treason.

Any person that volenteers to be part of the military knows that they have joined a fighting force and knows what the possivilities are.


Bob G
Rating
That he is breaking his oath. If he wasn't willing to follow orders he should not have enlisted in the first place. Now he will have to suffer the consequences of his bad choices. His own doing as he knew when he raised his and and gave his word that he might be called on to go to war.

It doesn't matter, his given word is his given word. He made the deal in full knowledge of what the deal entailed. If he gets prison time and screws up the rest of his life, that is because of his personal failure to act in an honorable fashion. I have no sympathy whatsoever.


Chance20_m
On the one hand I sympathize with him, and even buy a little of his argument, but he volunteered, he wasn't drafted. And in the 2-4 years of training leading up to his commission nobody made it a secret what his job was going to be, and the Iraq war has been in the news for 4+ years now. Yet he decides (what, a year ago?) that he doesn't want to do this now? Come on. Either do your duty or take your punishment like a man.


purplebuggy
He's an officer - he should be going for his soldiers more than anyone else and 2. because he's in the Army and that's part of his job, if he didn't like it he shouldn't have joined!


Curt
I think he shoud of thought about that before he signed up. It makes me sick to be honest.


D Low
Wow, ok, well, this one is personal. The closest person in my life is in Baghdad, I never wanted to see her go, and when she walked onto that bus it was, it, I can't even speak about it. If you know history you know that there has always been war, and if you know life you know you shouldn't be afraid. I think the officer needs to stand up, and live in this life, and quit being afraid...


kurticus1024
Rating
it reminds me of the Monty Python episode

an officer is quitting, he insists on the application he said, NO Killing, the general says why did you join then, he says for the travel mostly


GRUMPY
Good for him. Now take away his rank, bust him down to private, put him in the stockade and when he gets out give him a DISHONORABLE discharge.


k3s793
Rating
Court martial him and put him in a military prison in Iraq.


winemkr
Rating
Court Martial, dishonorable discharge, prison.


morgansway3
Rating
He should have known what he was getting into in the first place when he signed up. My 23 year old sister is a Sargent in the army and just had a daughter 5 months ago...she was shipped out to Iraq two days before Christmas for a year tour without her child of course. He should do what he swore he would in the beginning


Krissy
Rating
well you may not like being there but why did you join in the first place. my close friend is a maj in the army and went so you should go.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What does a suicide bomber think in those last few seconds?
Is it maddness, hate, rage or have they been cleverly brainwashed into believing someone else's selfish cause?
I'm in the bussiness of saving lives so I can't comprehend taking ...


 Should bush be impeached?
george bush makes me feel like i could be president that's how poor of a president it think he is and im sorry for those of you who disagree but you have to understand that he has had alot of ...


 Who likes President Bush?
...


 Who would win this battle 10,000 Spartans or 100,000 Marines?
Both have modern weaponery and the Spartans tactics are tweaked for the 21st century. Keep in mind that the Spartans were trained since birth and know no pain or defeat....


 I am contemplating joining the military.?
I'm seventeen and I am thinking about joining the military for no other reason then to serve the country that has done so much for me. However my mother doesn't take me seriously all she ...


 Is it OK to say "I told you so" at a militry funeral for a dead soldier killed in Iraq?
I belong to the American Legion and we are going to a military funeral this Sunday and I want to say to the war supporters "I told you he would die being so Gung Ho". Should I gloat? Should ...


 What time is 20:30 in military time?
10 points guaranteed for best ...


 If Saddam really had WMD's like the Pro-War camp now insists, why didn't Saddam use them against us?
Was it because Saddam was such a nice guy that he would rather lose all his power, his family, and his life than to use his vast stockpiles against those nice invading Americans? Something doesn'...


 Is a Military draft a good idea?
...


 How do you feel about gays in the military?
Please state which country you are from along with your opinion. Americans please address don't ask don't tell. And Brits please respond with your thoughts and perceived public response to ...


 Would you be proud of me, if there was a draft instituted, for refusing to fight in Iraq?
Should i put myself up to die because an idiot like Bush is in office?...


 What is the best smell in the world?
...


 I want to fly American and Australian flag together outside my house offend you?
I am an Australian living in the US and want to fly both the American and Australian flags from the flag post on my front porch?

Would you be offended if you saw something like this in ...


 Is there a difference between freedom fighter and terrorist?

Additional Details
I don't know Beth. Still on the fence....


 Why is it wrong to ask a military soldier if he's killed anyone?
...


 Is my name too weak for the Marines?
My last name is Pelli, in a career field where you basically dont have a last name (i enlisted into the marines and leave for boot in 6 months) is my name too weak?...


 Who would america side with if an all out war broke out between the english and the irish?
...


 What would you fight/be prepared to die for?

Additional Details
Seems nobody here likes war - I don't either, as all life is important...mind you.......


 Don't Join The Military, they lie and then you die! Agree or Not?
Military recruitment starts in school and ends with a funeral during one of our on going wars for Democracy!...


 Why do you let your goverement send your sons to war?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.094