Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

What prevents our military from using force to overcome democracy and setting up a dictatorship?
Find answers to your legal question.





What prevents our military from using force to overcome democracy and setting up a dictatorship?

It seems to be taken for granted that we do not operate like a banana republic; that there are checks and balances that make the U.S. different. But, what are they? If the one with the biggest stick wins, wouldn't that be the most influential U.S. military leader? If the military marched into the White House and told Bush to get out, what could he do?
It seems like a sophomoric question but I've never heard an answer.


    




happywjc
Each state has a National Guard,Air National Guard, whose 1st boss is the Governor, and 50 Governors won't/can't allow this to happen!! And in the event of a possible coup, theirs a million&1/2 ole vets would bear their arms!!! I'll never support gun control, as this may be our last defense!! And for those who indorce/believe that we live in a dictatorship now, just pack up your crap and go back to where you came FROM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Dani
Any coup in the making would be smashed like a bug. Really, that's not even a little bit feasible.


songbird092962
Rating
Belief. That's right, I said belief. It is the simple belief in the things our Constitution and Bill of Rights stands for. The men and women of our totally voluntary military believe in the ideals stated in these documents. They believe, as do most U.S. citizens, that those ideals are what have made our country great. And so they have taken an oath to uphold those ideals even unto death.
If a General decided to pull off a coup he might have a small core of soldiers support him but the vast majority would consider it an unlawfull order and refuse to participate. Even act to stop it.


2nd AD/ 4th ID
Easy answer, it would be an unlawful act. I took an Oath to uphold the Constitution and will not betray that Oath. I served the C-I-C and if need be would protect whoever that might be with my life.


darrell m
Rating
you didn't listen very well in school did you? or could it be that it is not being taught in school anymore? read the constitution and understand what it is saying. don't read it and understand what you want it to say like a a lot of liberals do.
outside of the legal reasons here are a few for you to ponder.
HONESTY
INTEGRITY
PRIDE
LOYALTY
FREEDOM


johnboy
Reality time folks
1 We are a nation of law and order though we whine never ending we love to see the bad guy put down its our DNA.
2. No president could ever be a dictator because he wouldn't last in office. Look at the heat JR is taking for Iraq
3 We use our VOTES to clean house from town government to the white house we have the say who runs the USA....


Victor Bout
Rating
Simple, it's called the oath:

"I, _____, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the orders of the President of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over me, according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice. So help me God." (Title 10, US Code; Act of 5 May 1960 replacing the wording first adopted in 1789, with amendment effective 5 October 1962).

http://www.army.mil/cmh-pg/faq/oaths.htm


Ben
Half of the leader's troops would mutiny anyways because they wouldn't be stupid enough to participate in a coup.


The Scorpion
Rating
1. The American people are armed to the teeth.
2. We have a history of following the Constitution in broad terms.


NSA
Rating
That would accomplish nothing. Why would anybody want to do that?


MILT FAMEY
i've had just about enough of that TREASONIST TALK by the "euroupian" If he were a U.S. citizen he should face a firing squad!


SgtG'sLilOne
Rating
its just not going to happen! thats what our military is there for.


Mr. J
It's called "people rising up." Citizens would take a stand....and there are more citizens than military men. Much like the "farmers" vs. the military men. Remember history class?


bdog1321
Rating
the could not do that, legally, as bush controls unquestionably where the troops are mobilized and their actions. this scenario is illegal for the military to execute and would be discounted without anything happening to bush.


Scott K
They could, haven't and most likely won't. The army is currently overextended throughout the world. If the military was to take over the government, it'd still have to deal with over 300 million citizens who would not take well to a coup. Also, the military most likely knows a stable government is best for the USA currently and forever, as can be seen from Burma and Pakistan, both failed militarily led countries.


writersbIock2006
/WHAT BUSH has done with the U.S. can only be considered as a dictatorship here.
Hes exploited every loophole, played every political hand,to create a dictatorship from within a democracy.

checks and balances is very very hard when you have half the government in support of this dictatorship, essentially stonewalling the otherside of congress from truly offering checks and balances.

The Republican party is just as guilty as bush is for allowing this terrible, ruthless evil group weaken our nation


citoyen du monde
Rating
America already has a Dictatorship!! And those checks and balances that you believe are there to keep the military from taking over do not exist.. The military and gets more money than any other institution in America.. and that will never change. Now just because they are not running around in the streets and policing you does not mean they are not in charge..

As long as Ameicans's keep supporting blindly, the Military then the Military has no reason to put tanks in the streets.. It has already all the power


alarafan
Rating
the US does use military force to set up american dictatorships all over the world. dont kid yourself.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do muslim militants fight like cowards with their faces covered and hiding behind bushes?
a real man and soldier meets on the battlefield and fights face to ...


 What do you think is the best combat rifle?
What do you think is the best combat rifle out there today? I think it is the m 16 what about you?...


 Is the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints true?
...


 Are marines really freaking crazy?
Do the people in the marine corps have a problem like everybody is telling me. Are they really maniacs?...


 Why are Dems not smart enough to see this?
The Left thinks Iraq is a killing field for Americans. Actually, it is a killing field for our enemies, at a very great but vitally important sacrifice. That reflects a grand strategy, tailored to ...


 Would i be good in the marines?
I can beat a lot of military games on the hardest difficulty its not to hard for me i am a good sniper i can allways beat my friends and they all say i should go into the marines....


 What is the down to earth reason the military doesn't want Obama as President?

Additional Details
Under Bush many have died. (For what reason?)...


 Why did allied soldiers in WW1 and WW2 suffer from shellshock, while their german counterparts didn't?
This is puzzling me....


 Do male and female soldiers in the army have much contact with eachother?
I know they'd obviously sleep in different areas but how often do they see eachother? Do some women 'fight on the frontline' too? sorry if I offend anyone Im just curious what womens ...


 Can active duty military members drive on an expired drivers license.?
...


 It's sort of a war question.?
so let's say you're writing a story
and a character in said story is expressing his views on the war.

i know this sounds a little dumb but:
since it's technically ...


 I want to join the army but i have acne issues. ?
Does this mean i could possibly get medically discharged?...


 Does a Reservist have to attend their Annual Training?
I am an army reservist who has some personal issues going on do I have to attend my AT?...


 How Much do you love your country?
Look at the days we are living in. Wars and Rumors of wars. If we found ourselves in a huge bloodbath with maybe Iran or anyone else do you love your country enough to serve it if there was a US ...


 How Does Having a Yellow Magnet On Your Car That Says "Support the Troops" Help The Troops?
The company that began making those in 2003 stopped when they realized it wasn't profitable anymore and that Chinese companies were doing the same thing. Does that magnet mean anything? Does it ...


 Why do SOME Americans think the Battle of Britain took place AFTER the United States entered the war?
instead of in 1940, when it actually did take place?

I am not saying that ALL Americans think this, as most Americans know it was fought in 1940, but why does that small minority think ...


 Back then in the 1700s, why the British Red Coats they march forward in the battle field & getting shot?
Hi everyone seen the movie like "Patriots" (Mel Gibson)? Why the British soldiers they march forward. Even they get shot, they still march forward until face to face. Why???http://www....


 Dirty bombs, why have'nt terrorists employed them yet?
DIRTY BOMB meaning a conventional type ordnance containing radio-active,chemical or biological materiel.
The dissemination methods are there, radioactive or other"dirty" materiels ...


 Why is America stockpiling nuclear weapons? Who are they going to protect the world from?
Why have they got so many nuclear bombs? And lots of rockets and things that kill people? Who are they going to protect the rest of the world from?
Is there a country who we are in danger from?<...


 Why is everybody who joined the US army considered a hero?
Fact - They get paid for their job
Fact - There are places in the US that are more dangerous that Iraq
Fact - 500 X more American civilians die every day from murder, car accidents, ..... ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024