Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Which would hurt more?
Find answers to your legal question.





Which would hurt more?

being shot in the neck at close range or falling off a moving tank at 40 mph ?
Additional Details
say you were shot by a 9mm I ask this question because I was the person that fell from a bradley in 03, my friend was shot in the neck knocked me off the brad which he claims saved my life because he believe that I was the one that suppose to get hit


    




Dave M
Rating
Falling off of the Tank, a close range neck wound would clean your clock in short order.


schester3
Rating
Being shot in the neck while riding on a tank moving 40 MPH, knocking you off the tank and over the side of a bridge onto a briar patch below infested wire fire ants.


fairy_dust
Rating
It's impossible to actually know for definate which one would hurt more because it would be impossible to experience both (seeing as you'd be dead from being shot in the neck at close range) but I think being shot in the neck would hurt more because you'd most definately die, whether as if you fell off a moving tank at 40mph and had stunt training you could know how to roll. Mind you, I doubt many people that have fallen off a tank moving at 40mph have had training as a stunt man... Still, I think that's an intersting question so I'm going to give you a star!


Rawbert
Rating
Getting stabbed with a spoon.
The neck shot would only hurt in certain areas.
Falling off a tank while moving, you could hurt multiple areas. Break bones, road rash, cuts, concussion...

Never fallen off, but seen people walk off a stationary tank and get hurt.

You can easily live from either or be killed by either.
I've been shot and it wasn't until the doctors showed me the wound did it start hurting.


oldmarine08
Don't know about being shot at close range but long range hurts, never been on a tank!

USMC Vietnam 68


Numbskull
A gun shot to the neck would certainly be a devastating injury,yet the victim would most likely feel very little pain.
Now falling from a tank at 40 MPH,that sh#@ hurts!


EverydayJoe
Being hit the the crotch my an asteroid the size and shape of Canada.


Scott S
Rating
falling off a tank after being shot


lisab
Rating
You would probably die pretty fast if shot in the next at close range. Depending on the weapon. You have a good chance of hitting the carotid artery or hitting the spine etc.

I would say falling off the tank you would suffer more.


Mel-Mel
falling off a moving tank at 40 miles an hr
i have been shot and i didnt feel a thing so yeah falling off a tank would hurt way worse


stefo66
Rating
depends. are we talking about being shot with a spitball here? or talking about falling onto a mattress?

or are we talking shot with a nailgun and falling off a moving tank onto nails, barbed wire, and broken glass?

just thought id be awekward =P


rogueriverbob
either one would most likely kill you,.....a longer pain would be a good swift kick in the nuts,.....


hyperjuize
Falling off the tank,
The shot will most likley kill you


Dvllover666
Rating
I think being shot in the neck at close range would hurt a lot more, but it depends, when you fall off the tank what all you would hit. It could be an on going fall from a cliff, to rock, to trees. Could even roll into a bear and get messed up. ^.-


sapper_12b4h
looking for a way out of the service?

Just go kiss your commanding officer. Its a lot less painful!


none
Rating
Just tuck-n-roll from the tank. Can't dodge the bullet at any range. Road rash better than bullet wound anyday.......


stopping the madness
Rating
Id probably die if i got shot and it be painless. I think the tank would hurt more


Red 7
Rating
I suspect the pain from being shot in the neck would be on one general location. However, falling from the tank, hoping you didn't get ran over by the track shoes could include broken bones and lots of abrasions over a large part of the body. I guess it would depend on the individual and their tolerance along with threshold for pain.


meshack
i think being shot in the neck!


Meister
Rating
The shot in da neck one, fo sho!


Mich
Rating
being shot would definatly hurt more


ruthaford_jive
Rating
Hmm... getting shot might severe some nerves so you might not even feel anything, and you might be a vegetable for the rest of your life, depending on where you get shot, but depending on where and how you land when falling off the tank, nothing at all might happen except a few bruises and broken bones, if that. I'd take my chances with the tank.


Nathan M
Rating
Falling off the tank, being shot in close proximity would be fatal in the kill zone ie neck.

USAF Vet - paratrooper


ilovehawkeye13
well I'd have to say falling off a tank. being shot in the neck you are pretty much instantly dead....but you could possibly have to live with the pain after falling off of the tank.


Hurshey
Rating
why? are u planning to hurt sumbody?


Kellie
Being shot of course.


Marquez J
Rating
being shot in the neck


Lisa G
Depends on if you get dragged by the tank or not. ^_^


x..Libra..lil..miss..septemba..x
Rating
Being shot would definately hurt more, falling of a car-like vehicle at only 40mph our would probably still enable you to live lol x

x..libra..lil..miss..septemba..x


dannad
Rating
shot. because if you fall off a tank you won't die.


Chad Foot
being shot in the neck definatly!!!!!!!!!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What are the advantages of going to college vs. staying in the military for 20 years?
...


 In my country(I live in Poland - middle Europe) most people think that USA is agressor(Iraq)?
USA are necessary in the world, only USA are able to fight whit terrorist, beceause Europa is weak. We don't have good army and gov. The people are scared(especialy after terrorist atack in M...


 If Aliens arrived and blew up the united states would you be upset?
...


 Which animal would be best to fire from a cannon?
If beseiging a castle, which animal if fired from a cannon would be most useful. I'm thinking tortoises, armadillos or maybe guinea pigs with explosive crash helmets on?...


 Why are women not allowed to be in combat units such as infantry, armor or artillary?
Relating to present-day and the war in Iraq......


 Whats better the Marines or The Army?
...


 Shouldn't boot camp instructors get arrested for pushing you too hard?
What if this happened:

Instructor: DROP DOWN AND GIVE ME 100 PUSH-UPS!

Trainee: YES SIR! 1, 2, 3, 4, 5......99, 100!

Instructor: 100 PUSH-UPS? TOO EASY! I WANT 10...


 Are people who spread vicious lies about our brave soldiers who risk (or have risked) their lives traitors?
John Kerry risked his life in Vietnam, served bravely and honoraboy, and was even shot. Yet there are people who spread lies about his brave service for his country. I think it's outrageous ...


 Where is Bin Ladin right now?
...


 Why are our armed forces so badly equipped and yet still the best in the world ??
...


 For those who support the Iraq war how do you feel when American / British troops commit war crimes?
Such as the baha musa case when the Britsh Army gave permision for soldiers to break the Geneva Convention and commit war crimes
http://www.guardian.co.u...


 WHATS THE POINT OF WAR?
i dont mean to shout but really what IS the point of war?...


 USA vs rest of the world - who would win?
Who would win a war between America and the rest of the world?

I think America would because we're the most powerful nation on Earth, and we have enough nukes to blow up the rest of ...


 This is not a Anti USA question?
How do American citizens feel about being the most hated Country in the world....
Additional Details
DID I NOT SAY THIS IS NOT ANTI USA....
I dont hate you I like you you're my ...


 I am really worried!! Military guys, please help!!?
Are there any military guys out there? My boyfriend is in the army and they went on a important exercise (where they use live ammunition). He told me that the exercise would only last 7 days and that ...


 How and Why dose friendly fire happen?!?
I understand that with going to war you have to think about the fact that you may not return but i have to ask WHY was a 19-year-old soldier who died in Afghanistan on August 23 killed by FRIENDLY ...


 Fools British!!!!!?
Fools British Falklands Islands actually called Malvinas Islands, and also not be enlarged because the islands are of us Argentines, only you are ambitious, and besides it makes very much remember ...


 What is the best hand self defense weapon to carry on you?
besides a ...


 Why am I ashamed to say to the world I live in the USA?
Source: Lost the Korean War....Lost Vietnam....Can't fight the weak insurgents in Iraq....Ran like scared dogs when the Marine Barracks was blown up in Oct 1983 killing 241 Marines...I can'...


 Is it right to hang saddam haussein for killing only soldiers?
saddam only killed militants, but george bush killed nearly 10 times as much as saddam (in iraq alone), including women and children. when is george bush gonna get the rope?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084