Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Would you consider the coast guard as being a miltary service?
Find answers to your legal question.





Would you consider the coast guard as being a miltary service?

Since its not DOD, its department of homeland security, would you consider it military? Are there any yahooers out there that have been in prior to 9/11 and still remain active? how has it changed? Also, how often have you been moved around?
Additional Details
the reason i ask this is that my girlfriends uncle was in the coast guard when it was DOD, and he was stationed around 7 different locations in 3 years. While on of my friends has been in it for 3 years and hasnt been moved yet.


    




Kitty
No, it is not. It is part of Uniformed Services. Which to put it simple alongside with Merchant Marines and those who work at NHS. You still get the ID Card. If you look closely is not a military ID Card but Uniformed Services which also includes military. So Military is part of Uniformed Services. So it is Homeland Security not DoD. They are two different branches.


Perro De Lava
Rating
Why not?? They are out in the gulf region wearing a uniform with the stars and stripes on it defending our freedom, so im gonna say YES, they are part of the military.


Ryan F
The United states Government considers it military... after the four regular branches the Coast Gaurd is our first line of defense...


Pyar
The Coast Guard is a military service.


blix_78
The coast guard is most definitely a military service.


imkevlar (boycott ignorance)
yes.


Chuck J
Yes the USCG is considered a military service. It is subject to the UCMJ and has the military pay scale. It's now part of Homeland Security but was DOT. Coasties deploy to every conflict the US undertakes and does an important mission well.


InReality01
Yes, Coast Guard is military service and counts as such.

My nephew recently served in the Coast Guard for around 6 years and was recently discharged and is now employed as a fire fighter.

I am quite proud of his service and it helped him tremendously in maturing and becoming a productive
person.

My nephew served in Floriday, the Bahama's and Kuwait during his enlistment. Had he stayed in longer he would of been able to put in for specific stations of his choice. The Coast Guard serves all over the globe and there is a lot of opportunity for travel.


Scriv
Yes it is military service. All enlistees must go to MEPS and swear in just like any other branch. They wear a uniform and even though they fall under the Department of Homeland Security they are still military. Even when they fell under the Department of Transportation they were still military.


PV2 Lake
yes the coast guard is a military branch


JMK_1
Rating
The Coast Guard is only count as part of the military during times of war. Any other time they are just part of the uniformed services.


desertviking_00
I do. And I'm retired from the Navy. I am in awe of the job the Coast Guard does. And, since September 11, 2001 they have had to ramp up port security as a vital task they perform. Most people don't realize that the Coast Guard has less total personnel than the number of uniformed police on the streets of New York City. Their manpower authorization is in the neighborhood of 38,000 personnel. How they do their job with such low numbers is a source of wonderment to me.


Bobo
You run a big risk by mixing the Coast Guard with DOD. The Coast Guard has the right to enforce laws on US citizens, DOD does not--DOD can only enforce the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) on members of the military.


backyardbum
Rating
YES!!! It is here to GUARD our COASTS while the Rest of the Military Branches have duties in other parts of the world. If something really did come up, they would sure get alot harder to LIVE WITH!!! They have more things ready if needed than we have ever seen and will only use them if they have to!!


Gigantaface
Yes, the Coast Guard is a branch of the military. They still deploy, even. I was deployed with a really awesome Coastie unit in 2004/05 to Guantanamo Bay in support of Op Enduring Freedom.
If I could do it all over again, I would have gone Coast Guard instead of Army.


h h
They are not part of the DoD unless we are in an officially declared war.

Until that time they are under the Department of Transportation, now Homeland Security.

They are very similar to the US Navy in their rank, and structure.

They may or may not be put under US Navy command for overseas operations however they are not part of the US Navy.

They have no representation in the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, their commander reports to the US Department of Transportation not the US Armed Forces.

Yeah they have aircraft, uniforms, ranks, weaponry (very limited), and might deploy as part of US missions so do a lot of non-military agencies like the FBI.

When you leave the US Coast Guard you are not considered a military veteran...nuff said.

They are a law enforcement agency plain and simple.


spkultr
because they got ships as big as the navy and they got
guns as big as the navy. and the like to shoot at things as
much as the navy does.


!truth!
Rating
If the U.S. Navy is a military, then the U.S. Coast Guard is a military.


gib000
Rating
I consider it a part of Homeland Security since it is not under the Department of Defense.


Shan
Rating
Yes, it is a part of the military, in spite of it's re-designation to Homeland Defense. There are Coast Guard members deployed to Iraq now. Just because your friend has not been transferred yet does not mean that it won't happen.


Hank H
Yes, It's under DOT, dept of Transportation, the marines are technically under Dept. of the Navy


game
Rating
yes, but screw them, Im in the marines


Monkeyboi
Rating
At best the Coast Gaurd could be catagorized as a paramilitary service, but they are more of a federal policing force than a military service.
While the men & women of the USCG do go into harms way to protect &serve their country (much Thanks to you brave folks) and the USCG comand has been transfered, when needed, to the DOD. their traditions & history are very different from those of the Army, Navy (including the USMC) or the USAF.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why can't we send U.S. gang members over to Iraq?
OK, America has a problem. We send out good responsible family members over to Iraq to fight for WHAT?

We have perfectly good gang members who already know how to "pop a cap" ...


 Why didnt US just threaten the british with nukes in the revolution war, instead?
of wqsting all those men??? WHenever we go to war we always say "no we cant us the nukes" but then why do we have them???? i dont think gorge washington was a wuss or anything but the ...


 Which country do you think is most powerfull worldwide?
In Military ...


 Is the US Army a good way to see the world?
The main reason I want to join the Army is to travel, but do you REALLY 'see the world' or do you just see the inside of an Army post for your entire deployment? I'm currently in Army ...


 What do you think of people that join the military?
...


 Headline: Soldier To Sue Military After 5th Army Deployment?
How does everyone feel about this? He feels it's unfair to deploy him a 5th time and require him to quit school and leave his wife and kids again. He's claiming that the financial losses ...


 At the commisary, how much do you tip the baggers if you take your own groceries to the car?
...


 If the United States were to go to war with China today, who would win?
...


 I'm thinking about joinging the Navy after i graduate High School. I'm a girl, and most of my girlfriends...
they think i'm crazy for wanting to join the military, but i'm so into it. I just need some outside opinion....


 How can I go and become a member of Hezbollah?
...


 In todays news..Why is the military forcing the soldiers to adopt fundalmental Christianity or be punished?
...


 I just joined the Marines and I get shipped off to basic training in 5 days. Can I quit?
I decided I don't want to join the military now.
Additional Details
I support Hillary and pulling our troops out of Iraq....


 Should I join the Army National Guard? Just wanting others' opinions...?
Ok. I'm 19, and I'm thinking about joining the national guard. I wiould like to be a medic, because I don't feel like I could kill someone unless they were directly attacking me or ...


 How to aviod being drafted?
I need to know if this is true can i still be drafted i am the last male in my family with my family name i heard that i couldn`t be drafted am i safe or is that b.s
Additional Details
i ...


 Did anyone serve in the U.S military? If so, how did you get in.?
I wanted go to the Airforce Academy in Colorado Springs,CO. It is a college that trains the students attending to become commissioned officers in the United states Arforce. It is only a "FOUR&...


 If Britain have all these suspected terrorist under surveillance, why are they letting more Muslims in?
Why not close the boarders until this sh!t is sorted out?
Send all the foreign prisoners back home forever.
Why does the goverment who we elected to represent us, not do what the majority ...


 Why did we go to war in Iraq???
i was just wondering because i dont uderstand it. So if someone can please it explain it to me....


 Should we prosecute George W. Bush and his War Team for the illegal war and mass killings in Iraq?
President Bush lied to the Americans on why he sent the American Army to illegal war in Iraq. He just wanted to cover his weakness of not being able to protect the Americans. Leaders form countries ...


 Ehud Barak says the IDF is the most 'moral army in the world'. Do you agree?
http://www.independent.c...


 Who was bobby sans or sands?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.064