Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Would you shoot a 6 year old child with an AK47 in its hand?
Find answers to your legal question.





Would you shoot a 6 year old child with an AK47 in its hand?

http://in.news.yahoo.com/070823/139/6jtc9.html
QUOTE "London, Aug.23 (ANI): Remnants of al Qaeda and Taliban are recruiting youngsters to fight British troops in southern and eastern Afghanistan. The Sun has video evidence of six-year-old boys handling AK-47 assault rifles....Terrorist commanders are gambling on our troops fatally hesitating before pulling the trigger if confronted with a boy," he added."
UNQUOTE

The questions are endless... but words of decency fail me here even though this tactic is, unfortunately nothing new to troops on the ground - even in Northern Ireland, children were used (throwing petrol bombs etc) and I'm not even going down the route of Africa !

I just wonder what the "do-gooders" have to say by way of a solution to protect these vulnerable children?...after all, in today's pc world, we're not allowed to shout at kids (mental abuse), smack our children (physical abuse); name-call (emotional abuse)...etc. etc. and this applies to new recruits...
Additional Details
It's a shame 6 year olds cannot read, or have access to Yahoo Q&A...
I concur with the responses and pray...


    




bildymooner
Yes but it would haunt me for the rest of my life. But life I will have.


Mike C
Rating
Would he shoot you ?? Of course he would. If you ever want to see your family again you will grow some fruit between your legs and pull the trigger.


Flyflinger
In a heart beat.
USMC 66-69


Fast & Furious
If it was them or me, yes. But would cry uncontrollably afterwards.


Robert M
Rating
Shoot to wound, if that was not a choice then to kill.


Pfo
Rating
If a 6 year old pointed an AK 47 at me I would try to take him out. It's sad, the kid is too young to realize what he is doing, and will probably lose his whole life, but I blame the person who put the gun in their hand to start with.


Ste B
i can't answer this better than bildymooner did.


thelev51
Rating
Sorry but as an ex squaddie I have to say yes I would its the bullet that kills who ever pulls the trigger be they 6 or 60 the target can still be dead.
In the early days of the Irish fun and games a group of 'ladies and kids' surrounded a 18 year old Argyle who was separated from his platoon, they frightened him took his rifle of him and Killed him with it, he couldn't understand it these ladies looked like his mom and sisters, He couldn't shoot them But they could Him sorry but I would rather live I wouldnt hesitate and yes I have been in similar situations and yes I am still alive.


??????????????????????
As an ex member of the British armed forces I would have to say no, at least not to start with. In war, if someone shoots at you you shoot back, no questions asked, just do it. If you are close enought to recognise that the person is six years old then you are close enough to deal with it another way, maybe... I've been to war and I have been shot at, but never have I been able to determine the age of the enemy who was trying to kill me. If these rag head b'stards want to recruit six year olds to fight against a trained army then the world is indeed a sad place. I'm very angry right now, send me a rag head terrorist now please, man to man.. and I will show you a grovelling coward.


vtjames33
Most of the world uses children, in many places they are forced to fight for fear that their families will be murdered. I would kill anyone coming at me with a weapon. I'd rather be remorseful than dead.
Of course John Kerry would shoot them in the back as they ran away- his words not mine


Patriotic Libertarian
Rating
This is going to sound harsh, but in a lot of muslim societies - the symbol of a child standing up to fight is idealized by their society. Against Israel, killed children are hailed as martyrs all the time - children that were given an idealized notion that it was a good idea to take on a tank with a rock.

How many posters and pictures have you seen that shows a small Palestinian boy using a sling-shot against an Israeli tank? Probably a lot. It's idealized like David vs. Goliath.

As a solution... their societies will need to stand up and stop letting their leaders idealize martyrdome. I can't see that there is much an outsider can do to change their societal views.


scout2116
Yes. And like all others you shoot to kill. He is.


Jamie79
Im affraid I would have to shoot them, it a heart beat!


dale w
i would blow holes in the 6year old kid without blinking an eyelid, hes a threat, its your or him, basic instinct is Survial if you dont follow instinted your as good as dead.


Rawbert
Yes. Hope they are killed that instant so they do not have to grow up with the horrors or missing limbs and friends.


NoAmnesty4U
Rating
Children threw grenades in Vietnam. Children are vulnerable to the adults who guide them. The evil recruitment of children has a long and despicable history. The children are brainwashed into believing what they are doing is right. It is horrible to misuse children in this way, but that doesn't make them less lethal. Troops would have to defend themselves from fire from a child. Their minds would be tormented by it, because the troops have been taught morality, but they also are taught to do their duty. I hope they don't hesitate to defend themselves. I hope the ones training the children rot in hell.


Damio
i don't care who it is if it's a choice between me and someone else i'm gonna shoot the ******* every time


russkimuzhik
Rating
If a 6-year old boy could lift 4kg rifle, he will be knocked down by a first recoil, and barely could hit anybody.

More danger comes from a bomb strapped to a kid by his evil uncles.


ironranger166
yes, and I wouldn't loose sleep at night either.

war is not a cookie cutter experience. children die. adults die. animals die.

If you are not willing to commit to acts of violence... meaning leathal force... then you are a liability to them men standing next to you.

I would not loose sleep over killing anyone because I know that my life and the life of my comrads are worth more to me than anyone that I may meet at the other end of a gun.


gordon3392
If you point a gun at anybody you must suffer the consequences,,,,


mandy
If they threaten an adult with a weapon, acting like they will shoot, they are just a casualty of war. Shoot them if you want to live.


Skippy
Rating
every human being as the obligation to protect their own life. I'm sorry but when this comes down to the choice of kill or be killed there is nothing that a soldier can do excpet shoot the child. If that child has been trained to use the weapon they are a soldier regardless of age. you could always argue the option of shooting to disarm but even if you capture the child they will be scarred, if not maimed and grow up in prison, not something the do-gooders would agree with either. If we are so ready to belive that boys who get hold of guns in the UK at an early age (Ok, not quite as early but pretty close) are monsters who kill wilfully, knowing thier own mind then why are we so ready to believe that these boys are any different? I know that they have no choice but a person with a gun is a threat and our troops have the right to defend their own lives from any man, child or beast who threatens it.


Snowy
This just demonstrates the evil and lack of humanity of the people we are dealing with.

If a loaded weapon was being pointed at me or one of my mates I would take the shot, however I guess it never leaves you.

The lesson from Africa is that child soldiers, who are usually abused, sadistically bullied, and have seen unimaginable horror become almost zombie like and fearless and as such are capable of things which adults are not.


bert
Rating
Yes,to a trained combat soldier,it's I.R.(instantanious reaction)


LEONARD W
Yes


ihurtmyhand
i would shoot to maime if it was possible but in that position its your life or theirs and i prefer to live


matt
Rating
yeah and i wouldn't give it a moments thought!at the end of the day if they're pointing a weapon at me or my mates in a threatening way then they're gonna get some and they probably won't do it again!


valf
Rating
If it was me or them I would shoot them......This is going to cause problems as I know how my son was affected in Ireland with the children there...This really shows what level these people will stoop to god help those children.......


frankturk50
Wi a second thought.It is obvious that the idiots who say they would try to wound him have never served in the armed forces.You only point a gun at someone you are going to kill - thats was drummed into me in my 5 years service.


dadseimaj
Rating
If my life or the lives of my comrades depended on it then... it would have to be yes.

Believe me a 6 yr old is just as capable of killing you as you are of killing him.

I would spend the next twenty or so years in therapy because I would have to live with that choice





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why do so many Americans pretend our soldiers aren't murdering innocent civilians?

Additional Details
I didn't say all our soldiers,, I said our soldiers... if they aren't our soldiers, who's are they?...


 Do you support the troops in Iraq?
Are you one of those who support the troops that are fighting for the freedom in Iraq? If you don't, at least explain your reason....


 Is it possible to invade the United States of America?
The answer is clearly NO, but I won't to hear what the disbelievers have to say... An invasion of America would be impossible. Even if the entire world came crashing down on America with a ...


 Why do people clap when soilders arrive at the airport?
I was at JFK the other day, and a plane arrived with a bunch of military guys, and they were all in their uniforms, and everyone started clapping when they walked through the terminal.

WTF...


 Wanted: Some well-wishes for my son in Iraq.?
Our son is a Marine serving in Iraq, and has about a month left. He is horribly home sick and losing his motivation. I'd like to start sending him words of encouragement to help boost his moral. ...


 When will Americans stand up and say "We don't want anymore of our men and women killed in Iraq!"
I say, give George Bush an M-16 and send him to Bagdad.

(and watch how fast the war comes to a close)
Additional Details
And to all you neocons, don't give me that crap ...


 If your son wanted to join the army ...?
would you try and discourage him in view of the current conflict in Iraq and Afghanistan. Would you be prepared for him to be killed whilst serving this country?...


 What does a suicide bomber think in those last few seconds?
Is it maddness, hate, rage or have they been cleverly brainwashed into believing someone else's selfish cause?
I'm in the bussiness of saving lives so I can't comprehend taking ...


 Should bush be impeached?
george bush makes me feel like i could be president that's how poor of a president it think he is and im sorry for those of you who disagree but you have to understand that he has had alot of ...


 Who likes President Bush?
...


 Who would win this battle 10,000 Spartans or 100,000 Marines?
Both have modern weaponery and the Spartans tactics are tweaked for the 21st century. Keep in mind that the Spartans were trained since birth and know no pain or defeat....


 I am contemplating joining the military.?
I'm seventeen and I am thinking about joining the military for no other reason then to serve the country that has done so much for me. However my mother doesn't take me seriously all she ...


 Is it OK to say "I told you so" at a militry funeral for a dead soldier killed in Iraq?
I belong to the American Legion and we are going to a military funeral this Sunday and I want to say to the war supporters "I told you he would die being so Gung Ho". Should I gloat? Should ...


 What time is 20:30 in military time?
10 points guaranteed for best ...


 If Saddam really had WMD's like the Pro-War camp now insists, why didn't Saddam use them against us?
Was it because Saddam was such a nice guy that he would rather lose all his power, his family, and his life than to use his vast stockpiles against those nice invading Americans? Something doesn'...


 Is a Military draft a good idea?
...


 How do you feel about gays in the military?
Please state which country you are from along with your opinion. Americans please address don't ask don't tell. And Brits please respond with your thoughts and perceived public response to ...


 Would you be proud of me, if there was a draft instituted, for refusing to fight in Iraq?
Should i put myself up to die because an idiot like Bush is in office?...


 What is the best smell in the world?
...


 I want to fly American and Australian flag together outside my house offend you?
I am an Australian living in the US and want to fly both the American and Australian flags from the flag post on my front porch?

Would you be offended if you saw something like this in ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074