Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Cars & Transportation Safety

Should there be an upper age limit for vehicle drivers?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should there be an upper age limit for vehicle drivers?



    




candigirl_77091
Rating
Most definitely


emzie
Rating
hell yeah


little_friend
Yes yes yes yes they can (I said can) be much more dangerous than youngsters.


paulette7618
yes they should be retested at 60 then every 2 years after that

some old peaple think they own the road even if they are doing 25 in a 60


Tatochka
Rating
Instead of an age limit there should be yearly testing for everyone over 70 who is driving a car. They should have to take a test for vision, hearing and reflexes each year. Licenses could be renewed each year for the elderly which include the qualification test. That would solve a lot of problems.


Plant-man
Any thing over 70 should be behind the wheel of a car


?Master
Yes!
I have watched my Father-in Law, for the past 10 years deteriorate and his driving is now about 50% of what it used to be, his reactions have gone, I refuse to get into the car if he is driving.
he is now 80 years old and to my amazement, no ability test has cut in from DVLA. he is still driving. His friend is 80 years old and he is even worse.
This is wrong.


simark12
Yeah, probably wouldn't hurt.


LisaT
No, but after 65 drivers should have to take vision and driving tests on an annual basis.


♥ ♥ Miranda ♥ ♥
Rating
It depends on the individual they should have health checks and sight tests to make sure they are safe


SUPER-GLITCH
Rating
Speaking as a more mature driver, I would agree, but what and how would one go about it. I call the guys you refer to as the FLAT CAP BRIGADE, huge expensive cars, cannot see over the steering wheel, drives at the speed of walking, responses slowed by age, and loss of sight and hearing in a lot of cases.
However, in this day and age, loosing your wheels is horrific, as the small shops are gone, perhaps a good bus service would be the answer, but it does not look very hopeful!!!

I also recall a recent act passed through parliament, about AGEISM!?!? So tread careful! Tread VERY careful - lol


Mystical Oracle
There is a limit, it is controlled by your ability to pass the vision, knowledge and driving tests.


phyllis_neel
Rating
where vision, hearing, and reflexes are diminished--yes


Harshit Saxena
Rating
driver age can be 150 or more if he is able to drive


Candy
Rating
yes after seventy


jenny
Rating
hell yeah old people now a days. driving really slow at like 5mph or walking where ever the hell they want thinking they own the street. younsters maybe a bad thing but old people is a real bad thing. if u honk the horn or something u could scare them to death and then u have a dead person in a car and the car is driving off on to the high way. i think the licnes should stop or be tooken away once u turn 60 years of age thank u.


Dr David
Rating
Yes. That is the simple answer, but what age would it be?
I would say as soon as your too old to drive. For an example, my father had been driving for years, no accidents etc., but when he was 69, I noticed he was getting rather bad at reacting to increased traffic on the roads. When I mentioned this to him, he replied "I've been driving for years, and better than many other driver's" That was basically true, but it always comes down to your ability to drive, and not how good you are.

I think there should be regulations that require any car driver over the age of say, 55, to re-take a driving test, and take a medical.
Then again every 3 years. L.G.V. drivers, who already have more regulations on them with their ability to drive, should also be included if they drive a car as well.

Young drivers who commit a driving offence, should, in my opinion, also be considered to be required to re-take the test.

I like your question, and with careful thought by those who make all the laws and regulations for drivers, the roads would be a much safer place for all of us.


pb_pony
Rating
Read the statistics.

It's young drivers that cause all the problems.


Winnie
No! Over 70's have to declare any medical condition. I do admit that over a certain age responses do get slower so perhaps a driving test would be a sensible thing for over 75's.


Coconuts
Rating
I think at like 50 people should have to start taking driving tests again but there are lots of people that are in there 70 or even older that are great drivers and dont need to be tested but if there is a set age it is a good thing because then people are not getting into accidents


GB123
No, but a Brain test for women drivers

Thats Progress


roobies mam
Rating
Yes, a n elderly lady(80years young) has just been banned from driving for going the wrong way up a motorway!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!the mind just boggles.


Jamie
Rating
No there should not be an upper age limit for senior vehicle drivers BUT there should be an age limit where redoing a drivers test becomes mandatory.

BUT let's not just isolate Seniors for retesting. Redoing a drivers test should also be mandatory for certain traffic violations and repeat driving offenders. Driving has to become a privilege and not a right for all people who choose to drive.


monster_monte
Rating
Yes when you see old people driving around with their mouths open. It's time to take their keys away.


Grandmom
Not a limit but a test to be taken yearly. Some people are aware and their reflexes good for a long time and others slow up considerably. The yearly test would keep tthe right people on the road and the right people off the road.


shaggybus
lets see what all the people that say yes think when they are that age and suddenly soneone takes away their freedom and tells them to sit at home and wait to die. Age has absolutly NOTHING to do with it. its ABILITY. I think everyone, regardless of age should be tested regularly. There are plenty of people that should be taken off the road, some are old and some are not. Thinking that some magical age suddenly removes your ability to operate a car is just as stupid as thinking that somones religion makes them a terrorist, or their color makes them a criminal and so on. Put yourself in the other persons shoes before you decide what they should and shouldent be allowed to do


pepzi_bandit 2
I think persons should have to retake a basic driving test after a certain age, say 70/75


Nightrider
Rating
Court decides on all such matters.

Some 80-year olds are virile and jumping around with joy like 18 y.o. Some 18 y.o. are just the opposite. (My grandpa is a good example - he is still chasing skirts... tch...tch..!!) My son? a 18 y.o couch potato and drags his **** to even get up for a glass of water.

So, who decides? What gives?

Safety is important of course. Personal freedom is important too. This is where police do their job of pulling over drivers who drive erratic. Then the court decides. Makes sense?


strawman
Rating
Some people stop driving when they no longer feel safe on the road, others continue and drive in a much safer manner than many lunatics on the road. There are more than 20 people in Ireland still driving who've seen their 100th birthday.
I agree with the idea of a retest for certain offences, isn't that already the case for newly qualified drivers, 6 points in the first 2 years and you are banned then have to take retest, same for drunk driving offenders?


Gone
Rating
No. The greatest risk is from drivers under 25 who are responsible for the majority of accidents.


Speedo Inspector
Rating
No, but I think there should be stringent physical and mental testing implemented at a particular age. Vision, physical and mental reflexes should have to be tested.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 why are car seats supposed to be in the back seat and not the front seat?
besides airbags, because ive seen airbags in backseats and sides of cars too! plus ive seen someone put carseat in the front seat rear facing....


 What is your opinion on seat belts?
Do you wear them? Why or why not?...


 Reccommended distance before a turn for tractor trailer?
I am preparing for my Class 1 (tractor trailer) knowledge test, but I'm stuck on one question:

When approaching an intersection with the intent to turn (wherever practical) the driver ...


 What is the current maximum bumper height allowed for a car?
Is it federal, state or county enforced? Just curious, have been seeing a lot of HUGE wheels on regular cars.
Additional Details
Ohio, sorry, I should have mentioned that....


 pennsylvania driver's test question?
well i have been practicing my driving and parking for a while. my parallel parking is good 8/10 times. i got a few questions. 1) what are some things they ask you to do during the test? 2) what are ...


 are motorized standup scooters legal to ride on the side of the road in washington state?
so my friends live about a mile away and i usually ride my 125cc dirt bike to his house through a housing development and then just catch a trail off the side of the road. the homeowners accosiation ...


 what happens at a gas station...?
like if you fill up your car with 12 gallons (US) at the local gas station (12 American gallons is equivalent to 14 British Imperial gallons or 45 liters)- then you stop it at 12 gallons. However, ...


 is this legal to drive offroad in New Jersey?
http://www.tomaliscooter i want to buy this bike cause its cheap and want to know if its legal offroad in ...


 i want to put a coach in the back of my truck. can people ride in it legally?
...


 What does the road sign ''shoulder work ahead'' mean?
...


 having issues with learning how to drive?
ok so I am not a very good driver. :(

Especially not in downtown Atlanta traffic.

So in the morning times I drive to work (mom rides with me so she can drive the car back cause ...


 Tires in hot weather?
How much air should I keep in my tires when the temperature is 95 and rising daily?...


 What are ways to maintain your focus when driving?
Hey, I've noticed that there are times, when I've driven down a pathway that I've done many times, my mind tends to go on "autopilot" because I'm so familiar with the ...


 Loutish, law breaking drivers.....?
Is ther any particular reason why those in newer cars (presumably leased by their employers) seem to be moving from BMW's to Audis?
Additional Details
Who is J. Have noticed. O...


 WTF, PARKING on a residential street for 2 days, against law?
We have limited parking in our street and this guy who lives on the other side of the block came and parked his car in front of my house and left it there for 2 days. It was inconvenient for us to ...


 what seat should i put my 2 year old in?
now here is the tricky part. yes, she IS 2 years old, but she is ALSO 3 foot tall and a little over 40 pounds. the thing is, she is getting to be way too big for her car seat (she has an eddie bauer 3...


 Do you need a permit to put a sidewalk sign in front of your business in Seattle?
Everywhere you look as you walk through the busy foot-traffic areas of Cap Hill, Madison Valley, Fremont, etc., there are A frame signs on the sidewalks or grass strips between the sidewalk and road.<...


 I thought new cars were safer? What happened?
Some idiot in a 2010 Honda Civic rammed into my 1964 Cadillac from behind. I didn't notice he hit me but I did feel a slight bump. I stepped out of the car and noticed I had a tiny little scuff ...


 should speeding drivers should be fined?
IM DOING A EXPOSITION AND I REALLY NEED HELP!!!...


 Can someone explain to me why I got this question wrong on my permit test?
A red arrow pointing to the right on a traffic light means you may:
a) Turn in that direction after slowing and checking traffic
b) Not turn in that direction until the light turns green<...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014