Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Considering that abortion is legal, is it illegal for a dr to refuse to perform an abortion? ?
Find answers to your legal question.





Considering that abortion is legal, is it illegal for a dr to refuse to perform an abortion? ?



    




dontcachfire
a doctor can refuse anything as long as it doesnt endanger anyone. as long as having the baby isnt dangerous to the mother's health than the doctor can refuse to do it.


Blue Haired Old Lady
Rating
Yes. Doctors can refuse to perform abortions. That is their choice.


LLOYD DOBLER
Rating
Only if the pregnancy risks the life of the mother. Also, just a few months ago a ruling in the supreme court stated that they cannot refuse to do the procedure based on personal religious beliefs.


Coreh C
Rating
I do believe a person who does abortion does have the right to say no, but most people who do it, do it because they believe its right. It also depends on the state


Bryan
An abortion is not considered a life saving procedure in most cases so the answer is no.


connorsmom
Rating
It's up to the Doctor what he wants to do or not do. Unless he's an emergency room physician, and it's a life or death situation, then I think he's obligated to save the life, (of the mother, if that's the situation)


Buck Ofama
No, a doctor may refuse to do anything. A doctor is not bound to remove a splinter.
A doctor is required to perform to the best of his ability IF he /she gives care.


mike1942f
Rating
No, because it is a personal service and is not required by law. On the other hand, as with the pharmacists that are refusing to fill birth control or RU prescriptions, the oath of providing health services should obligate the doctor or pharmacist to know how to advise the patient - which doesn't mean "Travel 50 miles to Burg, there may be someone there."


Flying Pig a.k.a The Fat Lady
absolutely not. a doctor never has to perform a surgery that is against his or her morals.


dianee
Rating
she said is it ILLEGAL for a doctor to refuse to perform an abortion. the answer is no. he can choose to do whatever procedure he wants to do and not do.


Jessica P
Not in Florida


justkrisi
No it isn't....My brother knocked up some 17 year old and she tried to go and get one and they refused not because her guardian didn't consent but because she was upset about it and didn't want one.


theninjette
That doesn't make sense. An ear nose and throat doctor can refuse to perform surgery on your brain, because that's not his/her area.


Gardener for God(dmd)
Rating
No, I don't think a doctor is required to perform anything like this.

You simply need to find one who supports this.


blest_4x
No it would be illegal to force a dr to perform a procedure that goes against his own personal ethics, the first part of the Hippocratic oath is do no harm


John H
Rating
YEs a Doctor can refuse


DiverDown77
Rating
No it's not illegal for a dr. to perform an abortion, however, most abortions are performed at abortion clinics, therefore...I would think it would be difficult to find a doctor that would not perform one.


Steve O
Rating
No. Just because it's legal doesn't mean it's mandatory.

And if a law was passed making it mandatory for the doctor, how long until another law would be passed making it mandatory for some mothers?


Michael S
Legal on a federal level
judgeable on state level
refutable by any doctor, even if it was life threatening and illegal


Ryan
Rating
its official, willow 4th person from the top has just made the dumbest response I have ever seen.

what about freedom of choice these pro abortionist believe in? So what, the doctor cant have that choice NOT to do it?


roadhazzards
Rating
Not at all, it's a service they choose to provide or not to provide. Plastic Surgery is "legal" but you can't force a Doc to do it.


harry k
No.

The amazing thing about America is that the constitution grants us free will. We don't have to do anything we don't want to.



Morbius
Rating
There is no law compelling a doctor to perform an abortion, and not all of them do.


Just Me
No. A doctor can decide what operations he/she is willing to perform. If the doctor doesn't perform abotions, find one who does.

A doctor can refuse treatment for any reason. My Ob/Gyn won't treat a pregnancy in a women over 35. The risks are too great and she doesn't want to responsibility of what can go wrong. She will refer you to someone who will treat you, but personally she won't.


Jessica
No because of morals


Josh
Rating
Remove abortion and put smoking in there.

Smoking is legal. Is it illegal for a doctor to refuse to smoke, or refuse to give you a pack of cigarettes?

Nope.

Answer your question?


TyranusXX
No


rukidding
I don't think so unless they are working in a public facility like a city hospital.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 what do i haft to have to sue a hospital for wrongfull practice?
my daughter is 6 months old i took to the hospital for a high fever and they put a catherter in her,ever since then shes been screaming alot and noticed just a few minutes ago that her little hole ...


 Reckless Driving charge?
I recently got a Reckless driving ticket In Peachtree City Georgia. Now this city is special considering it has a network of golf cart paths of 90 miles that go through the city. I was driving ...


 If the Canadian health care system is so superior to ours, why do so many Canadians go to US care providers?
...


 drivers licence sscard and birth certificate stolen?
how do i get a copy of drivers license with no ss card or birth certificate, how do i get ss card and birth certificate with no drivers license? I don't know what to do, I lost my purse at ...


 What should I do for my irresponsible roommate...?
My roommate, who's also the owner of this house clogged the sink for about a week ago
and she's not really doing anything to fix it.

Problem is that she doesn't even do ...


 If I am trying to serve my ex with divorce papers, but he doesn't...?
live in the country, but his brother lives in the same city as me, but I don't know his address because I have not had contact with him for 7 years, is it sufficient to run a notice in the local ...


 How many here would consider illegal narcotics dealers, etc terrorists?
I do..
Additional Details
We now have an immense network in place to combat the issue. I think it's time....



Real Justice......


 What amendment should I base my Amicus Brief on?
I am supporting/attacking the law in Californian counties that don't allow toys in McDonald's happy meals. For my class, I must use a Constitutional Amendment to support/attack the C...


 why cant they just leave cigarettes alone!!?
does it pi** anyone else off that they pick on cigarettes so much...sin tax..constantly going up on the taxes of cigarettes...alcohol does as much damage..so does hot dogs lunch meat hamburgers chips....


 Trouble with relative over will-what can we do?
My husband is executor to his mothers estate-there was not much to it,some personal effects and a house.The house was to be sold-the money divided between my husband and his brother.His brother has ...


 Immigration: Are Dems suicidal enough to run on a platform that includes non-enforcement of immigration law?
The AZ immigration issue presents the clearest evidence of the priority of the Dem agenda (as insane as it is) over the preservation of the best interests of this country and its taxpaying citizens. ...


 Are those sites illegal that provide links to other sites that upload movies and tv shows?
I am just wondering because there are a million of them out there. Those sites that provide links to youtube or voeh with real movies... aret they illegal? I know those sites with real movies on ...


 company went in administration and was sold, am I eligible for redudancy pay?
my partner has been working for the same company for over 11 years, the company was going throw a rough patch and we were waiting for the redudancy pay that would hopefully be a good amount, then the ...


 I have worked for my employer for 18 months I have not recieved an employmernt contract what are my rights?

Additional Details
UK LAW, not a temp; yes yo should be given a ...


 Is it illegal to dance in a car?
Me and my best friend always dance in our cars (when someone else is driving us, and obviously just shake around, nothing too big and we stay with our seatbelts on) just for the fun of it and to see ...


 would it be legal to carry a sulphuric acid spray as a form of self defense?
i realized that a sulphuric acid spray would be much more effective than pepper spray, but is it legal??...


 Can someone be arrested for being to handsome?
...


 what exactly is a protection order & how do you go about getting it removed?
Apparently this happened 3 years ago and found out about it when traveling after having his passport checked in a foreign country. All is fine now, except I need to know how to get this protection ...


 Is it legal to kill someone during self defense?
say this dude has a gun to your head, are you allowed to choke him?...


 What should I do when someone is?
harassing me on the street ?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024