Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should 'Racism' be a crime?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should 'Racism' be a crime?

Should you be punished for your thoughts?


    




ibsaved21
well, thinking about racism isn't bad, really. what i mean by that is, no one can punish you for what you think. but if you go into a public place and announce racial remarks, you will be punished. severely, i might add.


working-teacher- thank God
Rating
yes... racism does no good to everyone.. in a society that shows itself to the world as a non-racist society then it is a ig crime and a reflection of what our society really stands for..


demestar
Rating
no because its your believes and nobody can tell you who to like and who not to like!


William S
Rating
absolutely not. although why would race be a problem for someone. personality I can understand


:D
no i dont think racism should be a crime even though racism isnt as bad as it was before it still exists. racism is inevitable.


Tara
Rating
no


wondertasticator
Rating
You cannot be punished for your thoughts, you have a right to free thinking. If you act on those thoughts then you can be punished.


Goose666
absolutely not. if that were to happen, a new revolution would occur, i think. i know I would revolt. if that was ineffective, i'd probably bolt to canada.


Godly Reality Check
Rating
There are many forms of racism in which some are a crime.


carlos
Of course not, your thoughts are left alone, at least the laws in the U.S.A say that your rights stand until you reach another person, it's your opinion, being racist, now if you show racism everywhere you go, you interefere with that person's rights, that should be punished. Did you understand anything above?


GoGo Girls
Rating
You can think what you like, but we already have laws on the books that cover this.


bubba
Rating
racism in action should be a crime


General H
Rating
If it was, Obama would have been arrested a long time ago.


Jerkwithhotsauce
Racism is already a crime, in the moral/ethical sense. So are you talking about monitoring thoughts? I'm pretty sure no one is around to check those, outside of God. I think God lets us (free choice again) think what we want to, and then each of us have to accept the consequences.


puma
Rating
No. Although racism is terrible and people should learn to accept each other, if racism was a crime, what would there be to stop the law enforcement from making disagreeing with the government a crime? Pretty soon, that kind of stuff could lead to socialism. We have a right to free speech and thought.


Dien
While I agree with hate crimes being punishable by law, I don't agree that thoughts of racism should be punished. That's like saying ignorant people should be punished for not knowing what others do, or that children should be shunned for not knowing as much as adults.

Well guess what: everyone is ignorant about something or another.

Racism is a form of ignorance, a learned one; it's also something that modern society doesn't tolerate. But it takes a patient person to educate and enlighten people from racist thoughts without berating or marginalizing them.

We have the right to think however we think and not be punished for our thoughts.


Tuna County
Racism itself shouldn't be a crime but it certainly is despicable.


Jimmy Chambliss
Rating
why not


Farooq M
Rating
Racism is bitter reality, one can not take it off from minds, books, society. It is in human blood.
Should one be punished for thoughts, it all depends if it is against "MIGHT IS RIGHT". Then yes.
Otherwise it is "FREEDOM OF SPEECH"


A.P.
Well if you're black, asian, or hispanic it should be. haha:) White Power!!!


Edith
Rating
no. freedom of speech is vital in society. racism is wrong, but you can't stop people thinking what they think and believing what they believe, that's called brainwashing, which can be just as bad. it could also never be moderated as a crime, there would be no force to command it to stop, without dipping into even worse things such as genocide and mass-lobotomies to keep it controlled. it is morally wrong, yes, but cannot be controlled by the police or anyone else. the most that one can do is frown upon it and embrace anti-racism.


Archer
No. Racism is wrong but this is the land of the free and people are allowed to think whatever. But it is illeagal to act on your thoughts of racism.


The Great Flamingo
It is remarkable to see how many people on here are in favor of criminalizing thought.

The sort of bad things that spring from racist, collectivist thought are already crimes, such as assault, murder, and expulsion from public places.

Making it a crime to think something is not only illogical, but almost impossible to prosecute justly. This is the difficulty with declaring certain offenses "hate crimes." How do you ascertain the intent of the perpetrator. I believe South Park did a particularly funny and biting episode on this topic.


Paradox
Should the pope be punished for being Catholic? Well, maybe. Lol. But seriously, no. No person should be punished for something that conceive, whether it is conceived by others differently or not.


Angie
Rating
You should not be punished for your thoughts.
But racism should not be encouraged, we are all of the HUMAN RACE!
We are not a COLOR or LANGUAGE!


Nashville Guy
Rating
In what country? Racism is a fact of life. It always has been, and always will be. It's prevalent in both black and white, and any other race you might want to throw in there. It's become worse over the last decade or so because of the "political correctness" crowd. It's as though we have become the United States of the offended.


Ancient Warrior DogueDe Bordeaux
I may not agree with what you have to say, but I will die for your right to say it!!!!!!

by the way what do you call affirmative action? Oh I forgot thats "good racism" yeah


Pinky
If that were the case every single person would be in jail.

Your thoughts are just that; yours...untill you ACT on your thoughts...then it can be a crime.


-doozer-
Rating
If that was so then Obama and Rev. Wright would in a heap of trouble!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What are going to be the reasons that.....?
the Obama administration will give for the bribe offered to Sestak? That President Bush did it? That it's just politics? Not a big deal? Rahm Emanuel gave Bill Clinton the go ahead to offer S...


 If someone faced the death penalty in their original trial would they face it again if ........?
If someone faced the death penalty in their original trial , but was sentenced to life in prison instead would they face the death penalty again if they were granted a retrial? TIA...


 Do you think a better stance needs to be taken against this kind of terrorist?
The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) staged a protest at the home of Greg Baer, a Bank of America executive. Five hundred union sponsored thugs arrived at the home, located in Montgomery C...


 Your right to protest ends when you infringe upon rights of others?
Your right to protest ends when you infringe upon the rights of others and terrorizing people in their homes is an infringement upon them, correct or not?...


 Why were there not any arrest?
The Montgomery County Police Department arrived after being called by a neighbor and dispersed the crowd but no charges were filed. Perhaps a multi-million dollar lawsuit against SEIU and the DC P...


 If we have the 10 Commandments why do we need the Noahide Laws?
I've read them both and find the 10 Commandments and Noahide Laws. They seem redundant.

Why do we need both?...


 Do you agree with Rand Paul, that children of illegal immigrants should NOT be given automatic US citizenship?
I was floored to find that I had common ground with the generally libertarian views of the Senatorial Candidate.

I KNOW that it is UNconstitutional currently, but it was made ...


 Can you sue someone for intervening with your ebay account?
A buyer (that refused to pay for an item I sold a couple weeks ago) is cloning accounts and intervening with my ebay auctions because he is the highest bidder (paying insanely high amounts of money ...


 if your living in Australia is it legal for a 16 year old to be with a 19 year old?
what can you do and what cant you do?...


 do i have one lawsuit, or two?
I leave the airport, get a taxi to go to a hotel at midnight because of it's cheap deal. I get out of the taxi, it speeds off leaving me at the hotel and I was there for 40 minutes waiting ...


 will a warrant for failure to appear in court appear on a CRIMINAL background check?
I am applying for a management position at Qdoba Mexican Grill. I am going to get a conditional job offer and they will run a CRIMINAL only background check. I believe I have a warrant for a ...


 If the Commerce Clause allows Congress to ban discrimination, . . .?
what activities would the federal government NOT have the power to control? What are some examples?...


 How do I get in contact with the person who has the copyright of a song?
I am a student in high school who is in the band. My hobby is to create movies. Whenever I use copyrighted songs in the movies I create, I need to get permission by the person or group that owns ...


 Which year did the Pound note cease to be legal tender ?
...


 Is it against the law to blare police siren sounds from my car stereo while driving?
...


 A citizen who needs a gun?
I am going to to purchased a license gun for my own safety. If someone off the street pulls out a knife, and is attempting to throw it at me or slash me with it do I have the right as a U.S citizen ...


 Dilemma regarding current job and new opportunity?
I am having a dilema, I recently got a new job, just completed my first week. I have now been contacted by another company for a second and final interview which will be a day long psycometric test. I...


 What would you do if u are a doctor and....?
ok a serial-killer was sentenced to death, and while he was walking to his death room he get sicks he falls down, so the cops took him to the hospital and the doctor is you, so u find out that he ...


 can a lawyer do this?
Ex-son in law just received a letter from his lawyer stating that she will be charging him for not telling her everything in his disability/ssi court case.She is claiming he was not up front with her ...


 what is your thoughts on "the arizona law" about illegal immigration?
would all or some states benefit with similar laws?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084