Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

What do NRA supporters have to say about yesterday's shooting?
Find answers to your legal question.





What do NRA supporters have to say about yesterday's shooting?

Try to imagine that one of your loved ones was killed in the massacre, and then justify why guns should not be made completely illegal.
Additional Details
First, let me say thanks for the huge response. Second, let me address typical responses. 1. "People kill people" True. But guns make it EASIER. 2. If more people had guns, the massacre may have been prevented. Not necessarily. If more people had guns, through all the confusion it may have turned into an all-out shootout with even more people dead. 3. We should have the right to protect ourselves. TRUE. BUT EVEN IF THOSE STUDENTS HAD GUNS, THEY WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ABLE TO STOP THAT LUNATIC. He struck without warning. What would a gun have done for them? 4. Even if guns were banned, people would still die or be killed with bombs, cars, etc. TRUE. But cars are not designed to kill. Guns ARE. And it is very easy to kill with a gun. So if they are banned, that's one less source to worry about. 5. Even if guns were banned, criminals will still use guns. TRUE. But it will be more difficult for them!!!! That could make the difference between having millions of guns in people's hands and less.


    




alpha66
Rating
if you outlaw guns..then only outlaws will have guns ! he was an alien...he had no legal right to have 2 pistols !! too bad atleast one of the students didn't have one to shoot HIM with !!!...would have saved alot of lives.


Coasty
Why was an non-citizen able to buy weapons? Why were no ROTC students permitted concealed weapons permits to protect themselves and other students on campus? Just because someone gets drunk and killed my aunt and three cousins while driving drunk I do not want them to ban cars or alcohol why should the families want to ban guns. Why not ban immigrants? The guns were tools it was the mind behind them that was dangerous!


DAR
Rating
I'd want my loved one to have had a gun to protect himself and his classmates.

Over half a million guns are floating around this country - purchased legally. Why should only the good guys be limited?


plhudson01
Rating
alright I will imagine it. but the truth of the matter is one of my family members would have blown that guys head off and he wouldn't have been able to kill all of those other people


usaf.primebeef
Why don't you think????

What if just ONE of those kids in that classroom would have had a gun, then they could have stopped that person from killing all those that he did.

Besides it WASN'T the GUN, it was the unstable person behind the gun.
That is who needs to be controlled, not the guns.

I've had guns for over 40 years and I've never killed anyone, nor have my guns.


I'm so cool
Rating
If you want to worry about making something illegal that takes lives--then you need to make Alcohol illegal--it kills 4 times more people each year than guns--Guns also protect us, Alcohol does not protect us in anyway--even with incidents like yesterday--Alcohol is way more dangerous, and deadly yet you don't hear people demanding us to get rid of it, you know what also kills more people than guns--Car accidents, you know what else kills more than guns Tobacco--hum if we are going of get rid of things that kill us we have a long road ahead of us--maybe we should just educated, and live in a free society.


Handy man
Rating
_____________________In case you plan to read all of these answers, I'd like to proclaim that the right to bare arms is a basic right. It allows us to protect our homes and keeps us from being invaded. Because our enemies know the population is armed. But as with any right, it deserves intelligent control.


KrazyKyngeKorny
It was not the guns that committed the crime. It was a person. So, sentence that PERSON to life in the gas chamber, and make it very public. Let the criminals know that misuse of guns will not be tolerated.

If you ban guns, only lawbreakers will have guns. So, when they choose to shoot, they will know law abiding citizens can't shoot back.
-


My Lord
That was an isolated incident. Thousands more die from car accidents than gun violence. Should we ban cars and trucks too..... We only need more stringent background checks for anyone that buys a gun.


Andy
Rating
I can honestly say I wouldn't blame the right to own a gun on the massacre. Marijuana is illegal but people can still get it, so why would guns be any different.


.............................
What led him up to that point..That is what needs to be fixed.


B.Kevorkian
Rating
The obvious response is that, if some of the victims had been armed, themselves, the massacre would have been ended earlier.

Some other points that could be made:

VA laws allowing guns to be carried to do not aply on campus.

The college campus was designated a gun-free zone.

The shooter had guns in his dorm room, in violation of both the law and the college policy.

So, the shooting illustrates the folly of gun control, not the need for it.


elmar66
Rating
Because most of us are smart enough to understand that creating new laws does NOTHING.

CRIMINALS don't obey laws, hence they are CRIMINALS!!!!

So if guns were banned no one would have guns? Try enforcing that law when the existing ones aren't even enforced.

New reports "Automatic weapons were used". WRONG!!! 9mm and .22 are NOT automatic SORRY. try again!!!!


?
Rating
Again, cut and paste:

As I have posted elsewhere, the crack head still gets his crack, the heroin addict still gets needles, the pot head still gets his weed, the meth addict still get his hit. These are all criminal acts punishable under our laws but for some strange reason the criminal is still able to get an illegal substance, laws mean nothing to the lawless.

Do you really think it is difficult for a CRIMINAL to get a firearm? Somehow I just don't see them undergoing a backgroud check.


Fair&Balanced
Guns were banned at VA Tech so he broke the law by going there with one. If a gun ban will guarantee not ONE single shot is again ever fired and that not ONE single person will EVER be killed or shot at again by a gun I will support it, otherwise it is meaningless.


Reported for insulting my belief
It was a sad thing that happened. But once again. He did it. No one made him and the gun did not make him. If a criminal wants a gun the criminal can find a gun.

If guns were to be banned then the only ones with guns are police and criminals. Just think how easy it is to smuggle drugs into this country. Now you ban guns, the amount of guns smuggled would sky rocket. If some one wants to get a gun it would be as hard as buying drugs. Which is not hard to do.


shark805
Rating
I am in full support of all those who lost someone near and dear. I think it was wrong in every sense of the word. That said, guns will never be outlawed, because only then, outlaws will carry guns. People will find a gun, or just start using makeshift explosives. Plus this country will never change a constitutional right like that.


MLaw
Rating
If some of the students or profs had a weapon on them they could have short circuited this guy before he killed all these people. It is the best argument in the world for easy concealed carry laws.


Armed Civilian
Because if one person had been allowed to carry a weapon, they MIGHT have stopped this lunatic. Example, because you obviously need one: Appalachian Bible College, two students ran to their car to retrieve weapons after some guy started shooting up their college.
Do you REALLY think that he couldn't have found a gun illegally to do what he did.


aspergerskitty
I'm pro-gun. My dad and grandfather both have guns for hunting. They are responible (guns unloaded and locked up). If we take away gun rights, only criminals will have guns. Besides "People kill people". If we got rid of guns people would still find ways to kill others. (bombs for example)


crphoto666
Rating
If those students were allowed to have guns, alot less of them would have died yesterday.


Philip McCrevice
I say I wish several of the students had some guns on them and blew him away!


ph_yo
Rating
I think this country would be in a world of hurt if they tried to revoke the any of the freedoms in the Bill of Rights.


vospire s
because if my loved one was allowed to carry on campus and had the training to use the gun, he/she could have saved lives by taking out the killer.


redstripedmama
Because criminals are always going to have guns no matter if a ban is justified. It's not guns killing it's people.


bolt1
An equal argument would be that STUDENT VISAS should be made illegal!


Sparkles
That he was a criminal with a gun. I am not, so I get to keep mine to defend myself. I also am going to support NRA and the freedom to have firearms. This keeps us from being a communist nation with no rights.


vtsztpu
It was a horrible and senseless tragedy. What gun owners would like to know is why VT security people are not permitted to carry weapons. Any lunatic with a gun owns the campus til the police can finally get there and find them.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Prince William Sound and now the Gulf of Mexico...what more do we need to learn about oil?
It has been reported that the Gulf oil leak now surpasses the tragedy of the Exxon-Valdez (now suggested to be known as the Exxon-Mobil Valdez). How 'bout we determine that the Gulf and all of ...


 Hi World community Plz give me just one answer...?
Why Muslims are blamed every where for terrorism....Although much terrorism is being done by many countries like Israel, USA, and others...they are teasing Muslims countries by coercive rule.....Why M...


 What are the requirements to becoming a notary public in el paso, texas?
...


 I'd quit. Wouldn't it be wiser to help BP instead of threatening to sue, tax, & prosecute them out of business?
If I was a BP employee, I would just quit or make it look like I was trying. What incentive does BP have to actually succeed in capping the oil spill? If the US is threatening to squash your company, ...


 Why do black congress persons hate strict ethics standards?
Nearly half of the members of the all-Democratic Congressional Black Caucus want to scale back the aggressive ethics procedures that Democrats trumpeted after gaining control of Congress. Rep. Marcia ...


 Will the upcoming law school cycle have more applicants than last year's?
Last year's law school application pool was horrendous.

Cornell saw a 52 percent increase in applicants.
20 percent more people took the LSAT than the previous year

...


 How long do judges serve on the bench?
I remember when I was 17 a new judge being elected and all--it was a major event in town.

I'm 29 now...and THE SAME JUDGE is still on the bench! Doesn't the city have elections ...


 can rent a center do this?
I purchased a ps3 from rent a center some time in march, while i stilll had my job. I recently lost my job and wasnt able to make payments. My mom went there to tell them that she would be making my ...


 Do you think its rude or not nice to not say anything when you see/hear someone sneeze?
Like saying "God bless you"?...


 Um is this legal thanks?
Im seventeen, from Arborfield England. I recently acquired a live frag grenade, WW2 era, from a friend who was paid by his mum to get rid of it, I paid fifty pounds for it, but Im not sure if it is ...


 Is it illegal or just in bad taste to have a public KKK rally in the middle of a park on the 4th of July?
Some buddies and I want to have a public KKK rally in the park on the 4th of july. We would do some chanting, singing, and protesting of the government. Now, I won't be using any racial slurs ...


 Would a child be taken into care if solicitors found out the parent smoked weed every day?
My boyfriend is taking his ex to court at the moment to get visitation rights to their son.

She is pulling every reason out of the bag to not allow him to see the child unless supervised. (...


 how long is too long to wait?
went to ssi/disability court 3 months ago.our lawyer informed us that social security wanted a new disability onset date.the lawyer said she would have us a paper in the mail informing us of the new ...


 How can I verify that an employer is legal?
If a person is considering working there. Is there somewhere to check if the place of business is legal?...


 Facebook BS??????????
So my boys girlfriend cheated on him and i posted something saying how she was lying because the guy had naked pictures of her and her fried said her mom can charge us with harassment and I said ...


 Question on student aid and work study?
Can they force a person to take a job if the only work available is in a job the student doesn't want to do?...


 Took a pre-interview test, is it fair that I didn't get results, but others did immediately?
I am a new graduate nurse amongst 40 other new grads who are trying to find jobs. Our local hospital posted some positions and most of my friends were called back for all of us to take a pre-test to ...


 Could we get in trouble for this?
We got a friend who is a security guard to go to someone's house and say "this is immigration enforcement! open up!" and the grandmother was there and she panicked and tried to run ...


 If someone pawns stolen property, does the owner have to pay to get it back?
An ex friend stole my new ipod nano and probably have pawned it already, I am just wondering even if I find what pawn shop it is at and get the police involved, do I have to buy the ipod back from ...


 a person I know got into some small time trouble in a tiny town in Missouri.?
when he went to court he asked for a public defender and was denied and told to get his own attorney. I know nothing about the law as I have never been in trouble but have always heard the words &...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074