Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Can Americans lay claim to helping the British win the Falklands war?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can Americans lay claim to helping the British win the Falklands war?

The reason I ask, is that they seem to claim to have won every other war since us allowing them their independence (although they will claim they won their independence).
Additional Details
Strike Eagle, I think America can also claim 'bullying' broken countries too.


    




Mazlow01
Yes because the Falklands war was such a triumph! Big deal you claimed a few island from Argentina that are covered in sheep and bird crap.


oddball
did they **** help us! we won that ourself they only time America help is when there is something in it for them other than that your on your own.


♣ My Brainhurts ♣
I understand that their was a lot of American pressure on the French to stop them resupplying the Argentinians with more Exocet's. I am looking forward to the film version where that was the sole conflict (war) winning strategy.


The Fat Controller
Rating
they will say with some justification that a lot of the intelligence on the Argentines was supplied by them.
by the way German mercenaries were a major factor in the war of independence !


dude.
Rating
Did you really need, or want, or even ask for our help? There's just no pleasing you people, you ***** when we stay out of it, you ***** when we get involved, you ***** when we try to avoid war and you ***** when we go to war.


strike_eagle29
Rating
FIRST OF ALL THE FALKLAND ISLANDS WAS NOT A WAR IS WAS HARDLY A BATTLE. WE WOULD NOT LAY CLAIM TO BULLYING A BUSTED COUNTRY AROUND.

SECOND WE WHIPPED YOUR *** FOR INDEPENDENCE. YOU BETTER READ THE HISTORY BOOKS, NOT THE BRITISH VERSION OF THE EVENTS BUT THE WORLD HISTORY VERSION OF EVENTS.

DID AMERICA SAVE YOUR AZZ IN WW2? OR WAS THAT A MYTH ALSO?


JW Dread
Please,,, Can we not leave our respective playgrounds and shake hands in the middle of the road.
Yours JW Dread


stanyazfan
Falklands nope you did that one on your own....no help from us....but as far as the revolution goes we beat the crap out of you.. it was a war of attrition and we lasted longer...then we beat you again in the war of 1812....or did you let us win that too??
you guys were doing a smash up job against Hitler too now that i think about it...if it weren't for us you would have herr in front of your name...


brian L
The only way America helped was in selling the RAF and RN sidewinder missiles which reeked havoc on the Argentine air force. We also sold them the SEA KING and CH-47 Chinooks that were so important in this campaign.


quarterback
Rating
Well, we dont lay claim to helpping you. Although we did give you moral support as well as send our carriers into the area in the event that one of yours was sunk. Thankfully it never happened.

As for your statement about " giving us our independence".
Your joking right? If not, there are many books on the American Revolution. Perhaps you should read a few of them.


ChrisC
Rating
Nah. You guys won that one fair and square, just like we beat you during our Revolutionary War.

Of course, to your credit, the soldiers fought well you just couldn't get the support from your country because of Napolean.


Flagbearer
No, it was fought soley by British troops using British equipment, though the Americans WANTED to help, and by the time they were ready to do so, the Falklands War was over!


Lt. Dan reborn
Rating
This is the one conflict in the 20th century that I am pretty sure you guys won by yourselves with minimal outside help. Once you laid claim to this HUGE island which takes at least 30 minutes to walk across, you could strut proudly in the streets, right guv?
I guess we won our Independence by your Royal grant in much the same way that Hitler allowed you guys to come to back to the Islands he took from you during the war, was that the Jersey islands? You seem to have a hard time hanging on to land with a "Jersey" in the name....


JC
you'd be surprised who helped us,,and yes the Americans did help us a great deal,with the use of intelligence and the Ascension Islands and a lot more,,the French helped an awful lot as well,


AlienJack J
Nope we sure can't, Why? because we didn't fight in falkland... You allowed us our independence? Please after we beat england shortly after they became a democracy.,


CLIVE C
The British forces kicked some ***. Well done.


Lake
Since when did the Brits "allow" us to gain our independence? Was history rewritten while I was away?


lundstroms2004
Whatever. The Falklands were won because of the courage of Madame Thatcher.

Our independence sent King George over-the-top into total insanity. Brittian did not allow us to be independent, we won it through attrition. Parliment realized that commerce was the reason to establish the colonies in the first place, and more commerce would be had with an allied colonies rather than a resentful and rebellious colony.

Parliment decided wisely that the war was unwinnable and unprofitable.


Duisend-poot
Rating
Not American or English but may i ask what would you have called yourself today if the Americans did not help [beat] the Germans out of Uk. You would have been called a German, not so. Don't be so unthankful.


billnted
allowing them their independence? THe pansy Brits got spanked. they had no choice but to leave us alone. they did not want to lose their whole empire on the little colonies? Who follows who to war these days?


Blondie08
Nope, nothing to do with them. Next question..


leedsmikey
Wait for the film. I'll bet Tom Hanks liberates Goose Green.
Still they did win WWII for us and solve the Enigma code and flew all the planes in the Battle of Britain. I suspect Churchill was probably a Yank.


Merovingian
Rating
No.....they steered well clear on that one.


?
Argentina had a stick...you British had a gun. And I think it is very easy for you to see who would have won.

SO, DON'T MAKE A FUSS ABOUT IT. IT WAS UNEVEN GAME.

WITHOUT US IN WWII, GERMANY WOULD HAVE SUNK YOUR ISLAND, PAL.


dadacoolone
Rating
Yes you allowed us to defeat you during the American revolution..thats how you allowed us our independence.? Strange analyse but ok believe what you want to believe..
Its an historical fact that America gave logistics and supplies to the royal navy..so yes we can lay claim to helping during the faklands war !


barn owl
Rating
I believe they did help with intelligence and surveillance


KC V â„¢
Rating
To say the United States and England don't share military "intelligence" and other shared assets would be furthest from the truth.

It's sad to see the position you take on whether or not the United States "won" or were "given" their independence.

I'd prefer to say that sadly both sides of the Revolution lost lives of which was unfortunate.

Instead of trying to "rub against the grain" by slurring who did what...suffice it to say that Americans won their independence because ... that's what history shows!

A very GOOD book written by David McCullough, "1776", shows stories from BOTH sides of the war. Mistakes made by both governments and personal diaries from soldiers who fought in the war!

Look at how similar our countries are and the common things we share instead of who's better than whom!

Best wishes!


Stupid Marxist
Rating
Nope, you Limeys can claim all the credit for that one.

Good show, old bean!

Your Harrier jets proved quite useful. We Americans approve of this technology and even retain some of these in our military. Again, my compliments.

EDIT: As a previous poster stated, the CIA did share intelligence and allowed you the use of our spy satellites. However, you may consider this a minimal contribution and you likely could have been victorious without it.


lancs lad
Firstly we did allow you your independence. It was decided that the war was to expensive and unnessecery. Less than 1500 British died in battle ( 18500 died of disease ) were as 8000 Americans died. We only had 60000 soldiers, 30000 of which were German mercenaries. The Americans had 250000. It was also Britain against France, Spain, Holland and the Colonies. When you come to think about it it wasnt the greatest achievement by the US. Without help from your allies we would of won and many of you probably wouldnt exist today because the British didnt take to kindly to uprisings and usually slaughted the people involved.

As for the war of 1812. No side won, the US was terrified of the British who swept through there armies with ease and the British were finding the US armies tactics difficult to handle although victory was only ever going to be for the British. Again the war was expensive and hard to keep going but it ended the US ever trying to invade Canada again and the British trying to regain the Colonies it had given up. Basically both sides gained nor lost anything.

The Falklands was 100% British. We fought it we won it ( very common when talking about the British ). Fot you Americans who say " wow you won a war against a vastly inferior army " can i remind you of a nice country called Iraq? You cant beat some ragheads. We might be there but we are doing much better, even having nearly got peace but then the US does something stupid like send 21000 troops over?. Then again you lost in Vietnam to a bunch of vastly inferior soldiers. Just remember that Britain doesnt underestermate its enemy and has the greatest military record of all time. In 1000 years we have lost no war ( wars are lost through surrender or capture of a leader/capital city ). Pretty good for an Army that once controlled the world with just 30000 soldiers.


Britain would never of been conquered by Germany. We defended our country and the Germans decided the better leave us alone so you Americans can stop saying that bollox cant you............well done, doest the truth make you feel better. There was more chance of the Germans taking over your country than there was ours after the Battle of Britain and Germany had plans and it was to be there next move because they couldnt ever beat Britain. Thankyou and goodnight.

CASE CLOSED





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is the president in the military?
I realize he is the Commander and Chief, but is that considered military service? If he is in the military is he considered to be simultaneously serving in all branches of the military? Does he carry ...


 When marching why does the military start off on the left foot?
...


 World War 2, nickname of German Retreat?
I can't remember what the nickname of this one retreat was called, but it's right at the tip of my tongue. I believe it was in France, and the Germans lost around 56,000 men to capture, ...


 Navy Recruitment Question?
if I signed up for the Navy tomorrow how fast could they deploy me?
Additional Details
I didn't mean deploy sorry how long would I have to wait till they send me to boot ...


 is it easier to do this, or that?
im not asking this for me, but for a friend.
he wants to know if its easier to become an Intel Officer by enlisting after college and going Intelligence Specialist then after 4 years, go to OCS,...


 Serving on submarines?
I plan on joining the navy and i want to do submarine service. I would like to know what qualifications i need and what i should know. I would prefer answers from someone in the navy or who actually ...


 I'd like to thank the men and women of the military for their commitment to keeping us safe. How about you?
http://www.youtube.com/w...


 Does the UK have the best special forces in the world?
I have heard from many people on this site that the SAS is the best special operations unit in the world and from some people in real life as well. Well, as an American I am a bit shocked because I ...


 Should it not be a matter of national principle to declare war on the Yanks for implementing a probe of BP?
...


 How long does the process takes if you tested positive on a drug test in Marines?
I have a friend in the Marines in Fort Leonard Wood, and he has test positive on a drug test for Marijuana and Ecstasy. He wants to leave the core, and wonders how long the process takes for the ...


 Help!! My daughter is having trouble?
My husband is in the marines and we are living far away from any of our relatives. We have a 4 year old little girl and she is not coping with the separation well at all! I let her talk to family ...


 .30-06 Springfield cartridge vs. .308 cartridge?
none of the *** holes over at hunting are answering my question.

I want to have the cartridge between these two that is superior in accuracy and power. I am going to be shooting a R...


 what would you do if you had a replica army like from the game F.E.A.R.?
the soldiers were trained to never fear never disobey never surrender and they could hear orders telepathically so they could obey no matter where you were at.

so what would you do?...


 What is that bird in the Marine Corps logo for?
I seen it on TV, and have no idea what it means....


 What is the difference the units of the Airborne Rangers & Ranger from the U.S. Army?
Hi I've seen some soldiers who wears only 1 gold ranger patch on his left arm & I see other guys who wears black,white, & red Airborne Ranger patch. What is the difference between the 2 ...


 a couple of questions about army rotc?
does army rotc pay full tuition if i get a scholarship? and if i get a scholarship, can i choose reserves? also will a scholarship increase my chances of getting active duty?...


 Is this now the standard issue camouflage for British troops in Afghanistan?
I saw this: http://www.royalnavy.mod (40 Commando, Royal Marines).

That multi-cam type camouflage, different from the desert one used previously, is that now a ...


 will the new fiscal year better my chances of joining the Marines ?
im 21 and 100% set to join the Marine Corps . ive talked with 2 recruiters and i have been having some trouble joining . i have a small hand tat that ive been getting removed . its def been holding ...


 What's the deal with all of the bad answers in the military section?
Between all of the ignorant questions coming out, such as people asking what are the chances of dying in the military, how can they join the military without ever going to war, how did your first ...


 What are the highest paying military(preferably Army or AirForce) jobs once transferred to civilian world?
I know all jobs pay the same. Im asking what are the highest pay jobs once in civilian world, with or without a degree. Thanks....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084