Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

I need examples of laws that are unjust and that morally right people are obligated to disobey!?
Find answers to your legal question.

I need examples of laws that are unjust and that morally right people are obligated to disobey!?

Current ones would be helpful but past works too!

Most answers so far are laws the posters disagree with. For morally right people to be obligated to disobey requires a higher standard than the law being unjust. The law would have to require people to do something that is morally wrong or prohibit something that is required by morality. I don't have any examples of actual laws at this time, but that is the standard I would use. Medical marijuana does not qualify under this standard because you have no moral obligation to smoke it.

Ol' Sasquatch
When we disobey a law of any sort, we are the unjust! While there are dumb laws, they are still laws and violating them makes us the criminal! No one is 'morally right' or 'obligated' to disobey a given law! If one considers a law to be unjust or foolish, one has the right (or even the responsibility) to fight it in a court of law! That said ... In Milwaukee, WI it is illegal to spit in a public place. However there is no fine (that I am aware of) for throwing-up in a public place. Hey, folk get sick when they get sick! Okay, not the best example! I would have to go along with the rest supporting pot for medicinal purpose! The Ol' Sasquatch √ú

to follow something that does not go along with their religious beliefs

Studbolt Slickrock
adultery and sodomy laws

matt s
Different races not being able to marry. Gay marriage ( all though I am opposed to it).

Super Trooper
In my state, it's against the law to feed the birds in the winter time.

Thomas S
Canada will refuse to extridite people to America if there is a chance they will be put to death. I know murder should be a crime but isn't that what the death penalty is. I'd say smoking pot. People don't have to do it but if they choose to it isn't wrong.

The draft in Vietnam, forcing soldiers to fight in Iraq. I agree with Thomas, there is no justice in making pot illegal... but I certainly wouldn't say anyone is obligated to disobey (except for medical purposes I suppose)

Our current personal income tax...but, you're on your own.

Laws against marijuana for medical use

Legal Discussion Forum

 was living common in law for 3 years can I get half of his estate?
This men made me move from a province to a another province to be with him, after 3 yrs of living common in law he cheated on me and asked me to move out. after 1 yrs of seperation I want to know if I...

 Do you know any crazy laws?
Here are a few I found from Canada. A teenager can't legally walk down the main street in Fort Qu'Appelle Saskatchewan with his shoes untied. People over 16 years of age were forbidden to ...

 can my employer tell me not to smoke?
i am working at a camp and my boss said i cant smoke from 7 am to 9 pm. is this legal?...

 I'm going to court for possesion, what should I expect?
My brother got arrested a month ago for possesion of Marijuana. He had less than an ounce on him and it was his first time in trouble with the police. He is going to court tomorrow - What should we ...

 New law in Canada, inmates can't publish ANY books. What do you think?
On June 27, 2002, BILL 69 was passed in Ontario, called "Prohibiting Profiting from Recounting Crimes Act, 2002". It basicly says no inmate can publish a book. Nor can his family, spouse, ...

 haw about if i choose to do time instead to pay the seatbelt fine?

 POLL: If you broke into future shop and got caught stealing?
If you and a friend broke into futureshop and got caught stealing murchandise but DIDNT get caught breaking in and the cops both brought you in seperately giving you two the same options what would ...

 Should Marijuana be legal in Canada for enjoyment of regular people...?
not just medicinal .. for people that just want to have ...

 How do I file a suit against someone who borrowed money and refused to pay me back?
A friend asked me to lend him some money back in February of this year, 2009 with a promise to pay me back in two weeks. He did not. I didn't start asking for the money back until last week of J...

 Would you do something that was illegal, but morally right?
Even if you knew it could get you many years in prison. Trust me, I am not talking about bombing anything....

 How is it that a lawyer can defend the Australian incest rapist???
he imprisoned his daughter for 24 years and fathered seven children with her... Isn't it obvious he is to recieve the full penalty+ more (with God) Like what could this lawyer dare defend? W...

 son was with friends, went to pawn shop, sold stolen stuff is he guilty?
my step son, was with a friend. went to a pawn shop and took computer equipment. my step son, took his computer, the friend took equipment stolen ( both knew it was stolen). what charges, if any, can ...

 who signs a bill to make it officially a law?

 I got caught stealing under $20 at Walmart whats going to happen to me?
I'm 16 years and this is my first offense. I live in Ontario Canada. I stole an energy drink, a pack of pens (for school) and cleaners for my fish aquarium. The security kicked me out of the ...

 my employee has been coucelled many times and still makes the same mistakes.?
He has been councelled several times for mistakes and continues to make them over and over again. He is not a good team player and his integrity is questionable, can't easily be trusted....

 why are so many government officials so against praying in schools and claim we have freedom in worship?

 is it illegal for my landlord to open my mail?
he delivers the mail to me downstairs, if i find that my mail's been cut opened before handing it to me is it illegal whats the punishment for ...

 Can we sue our landlord?
I am a young mother of four children. Recently I was away with the baby in the hospital.(He had Pnumonia) The landlord came and did an inspection, she had sent a notice a month ago and we forgot ...

 will i be able to join the national guard with serval felony charges ??

 If you buy drugs on the street aren't you guilty of contributing to crime and violence?
Even if it is only ...

Copyright (c) 2009-2013 Wiki Law 3k Sunday, February 7, 2016 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links