Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Marriage & Divorce

Should I check her phone calls?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should I check her phone calls?

My wife and I are separated. But we've been working on things.

She stood me up saturday night and didn't call me until monday afternoon.

I called the girl she lives with said she was okay.

I left two messages.

When she called me she said she was ill, which she does have a history of.

I don't believe she's lying about being sick, but I think she's stretching the truth.

I told her that I need to see her phone records, since she didn't make or answer any of my calls, then she shouldn't have answered any others. She said okay, because she didn't make or answer any calls.

Am I over reacting?







ideally_rational
She was so sick she couldn't pick up the phone and tell you?
Does she have a disease which makes her unconscious for days at a time?
Ask her what was really going on. It doesn't mean that she was cheating, but maybe she was taking a "thinking it through" weekend because the relationship is sitting on the fence, not sure which way it will go.
Give up the phone investigative work. If she really wants to talk to another man and doesn't want you to know, all she would have to do is use her roommate's phone or a pay phone or a million other ways...
I still smell a rat because she didn't give you the common decency to call you and let you know, but maybe your marriage has a history of disrespect and the two of you definitely need to work on that.


Kit Kat
If you doubt her, or dont trust her, what's the point in reconciling ?


Steve J
The whole "I need to check your phone records" thing is pretty creepy! Clearly she is trying to get away from you. I wouldn't be surprised if you wind up getting served with a restraining order soon.


blondie
yes your def over reacting and that's going to do nothing but push her away even more.. why would you want to be w/ her when you obviously don't trust her.. you should trust that she was sick and if you don't then why do you want to be w/her???


Penny
Rating
Maybe, she needs time alone and don't be bother while she's separating from you. She will tell you the truth if she wants to.


TroubleRose
Rating
I dont think you are, I would check it them anyway. The fact that she said ok proves that she doesnt have anything to hide. However, her lack of calling shows lack of communication which I feel is the main reason why divorce is at such a high percentage.

-Check the phone records
-Tell her to work on communication skills


me
well like everyone else said
but
a relationship will not work without trust


?
Rating
Uh... Yeah...

It was ONE time. If it happens again, then over-react.


...Melissa...
Rating
Absolutely. You are SEPARATED. Wether you are working on things or not its none or your business. How do you think you will be able to get back together when you dont trust her and she can't trust you. You need to tell her how you feel. Communication is important in any relationship. To work things out trust her, even if you don't think u can. Never snoop around on her. You will only find things you don't want. Or you will find things that are nothing but you will make them to be bigger than they are. Give her space


Kitten
Rating
If you dont trust her..then what the hell are you doing in trying to work things out? You are totally over reacting..you aren't her father. If I were her Id not only not give you my phone records, Id tell you to jump off a cliff.


2u
Rating
youre not normal;take your medicine


M.J.
Rating
no. if you are trying to make this work then there is nothing wrong with a little reassurance! dont go crazy about it but look at them and if she lied then hey you will know it just wont work and you can stop trying! but if she wasnt lying then apologize and never do it again. i say do it bud you need to know if it is worth trying to work out! good luck!


Kitten
Rating
Wow, i see why you don't live together...See her phone records? Are you insane? I'd be furious if my husband, even when separated from him, asked me to see my phone records to prove I had been telling the truth...

Yikes...walk away man, you need to move on.


mrsknowitall
Rating
Just a little and if you keep it up you guys will never reconcile. I can bet that you are th reason you guys are separated.


Texas Happy Horn
Rating
YES you are overreacting. You need to learn to trust her, if you can't trust then it is time to move on. Her phone records are none of your business and she should not have to show you them to you.

Your behavior would push me away for good. I hope it doesn't do the same to your wife.


cassiepiehoney
if you have to check up on her to get the truth-is the relationship really worth saving. try to really get through to her the importance of honesty-tell her if she wants out of a date-to please just tell you,that telling you she's sick -really just worries you and if she feels you cant handle the truth-that you will try to toughen up a little


Penny Lane
Rating
Listen, just because she didn't talk to you doesn't mean she was doing something destructive to your relationship.
She obviously didn't want to talk.
Leave her alone, you're separated for a reason. Don't make it worse.


zajucomom
Rating
If you're not paying for the phone. You have no right to see it.


Aces baby
if you dint believe her you can ask her whats the real reason for her standing you up but her phone records are her privacy and yeah you wanting to see them is way to much


anch49
Yeah you are. If the phone is hers you should have no reason to check her records. If you don't trust her then you don't need to be together period.


c
sort of, but no, its understandable, she should have at least called to let you know. If she was so ill that she couldn't even pick up the phone, and now she's all better? that sounds suspicious to me..


da best girl you kno!!!!
HECK YA!!!! leave her alone for a couple of days and get outta her business


magicgee
Rating
I agree with coolbennie maybe something did come up and your already jumping the gun.


Vergie
Yes you are over reacting........sounds like you need to do some work on yourself and leave her alone.


cupids_victim11
NO... i think thats normal... and its very cooperative of her to not argue about letting you see them... cus if she would have then that means problems


bootsontheroad
Rating
Let me put it this way, anyone sking to see my phone records is a control freak. Therfore, would not need to call ever again and I would get a court order to back it up.


Grace
Rating
Yes. Chill out. Asking to see her phone records is ridiculous.


skcs11
Rating
you two will never get along


Ива́н Гро́зный
☭ Right! ☭
-----------------

Check her phone calls (and her panties too!)
a man can never be to certain☭☭☭


Coolbeanie27
Now I see why you are separated.







Legal Discussion Forum

 Would you cheat on your spouse if you knew that nobody would find out about it?
And you were really attracted to this person....


 Why do women disobey their husbands ?
...


 what is the word for someone who marries frequently?
...


 My wife’s morning breath killed our house plants, how can I take that 1st morning kiss without passing-out?
...


 Should I have my wife sleep outside?
She has been sick for a couple of days and her sickness noises has been keeping me awake. So i was thinking that there is only one solution....


 should I be hurt/offended by my husband's "gift"?
I had our second baby four months ago, and I'm the first to admit I still have a tummy - I am never given a break to go to the gym or anything either.
Well, today my beloved husband came ...


 Would you marry a girl who is beautiful and has many wonderful qualities...but can't cook?
I have a lot of good points...but cooking definitely isn't one of them lol. But men seem to place so much importance on a woman's culinary skills. I'm 20 and I know many other girls my ...


 whats your secret to a happy marriage/relationship?
please share, I feel like I could use all the help I could get....


 do you think if a man has cheated on you, and lied numerous times you should still stay for the kids?
...


 Is Flirting OK if you are married ?
...


 My husband wants to be a swinger and I don't...What do I do?
My husband wants to us to be swingers and I am not interested in this lifestyle. I never have been and he knew that before we were married. He tells me that if I cared about him enough I would make ...


 alcoholic husband?
My husband is 24. He drunk last night 4 beers and 700ml rum (it usually comes in 30mls) the night before, he only had 2 ltrs of beer and a bottle of wine, but that was a work night. I am really ...


 Need an outside opinion.............Please help?
My husband and I have been struggling with issues of trust for quite some time now. Over the past couple months things were getting quite better. Anyway we both went out Saturday night, to ...


 if you find out your husband have a 6yr old and you have been married 12yrs what do you do and he has cheated?
my husband has a 6yr old and we have been married 12yr and this is not the first time he has cheated and now he claims he has changed what do i ...


 Do you expect your marriage to last your lifetime?
Going down the aisle, do you believe it will be forever or only hope it will? Do you expect complete faithfulness or do you expect your spouse to play around?...


 How do I tell my soon to be ex that I'm dating someone else?
We've been physically seperated about 7 months but have been emotionally seperated for quit some time.

Anyway...I'm dating a man totally opposite of my husband. He's ...


 If your husband tells your not his soul mate, should you pack your bags and leave?
...


 What happens if I stop making child support payments?
Baby's mother is getting married and we agreed awhile ago that I would relinquish my rights. I have been paying support since the child was born, but after recently coming to this agreement I�...


 If a casual friend I know asked me out for lunch and I want to go, is that cheating if I'm married?
I do want to go for lunch with her but since I'm married is that considered cheating?...


 Should i forbid my pregnant wife from swimming this summer so our baby doesn't risk drowning while underwater?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014