Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

can you get a higher rank in the US Army Green Berets than colonel?
Find answers to your legal question.





can you get a higher rank in the US Army Green Berets than colonel?

In Apocalypse Now, captain Willard said Kurtz joined the Green Berets, but he knew he'd never get above the rank of colonel. why is that?
please be detailed, and explain some other branches of the US Military too.







PetGriffin
In real life you can. Gen. McCrystal was an Army Special Forces solder (Green Beret). Don't go by a story line or script- the majority of it is BS. In other branches you can be in special operations and rank up as well.


Andy
It's a movie. At that time Special Forces officers were not just Special Forces officer like they are now with their own MOS. Most would only be Special Forces for a short time in their career than go back to a regular army position. They might very well return to Special Forces later, but it wasn't a career path back then.

General Henry Hugh Shelton climbed through the ranks and made four star General and was Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff from 1997 to 2001.


redleg_army
Apocalypse Now, while a good movie, was inaccurate in many respects. That being said...at that time Special Forces was not a separate branch, as it is now, but a specialty that was seen by many conventional Commander's as a drain on resources and good personnel.

In fact until 9-11 this view was still held by many conventional Commander's as a drain from the focus which was aimed at fighting the Soviets in a massive land war on the European continent.

That being said a Special Forces Officer stands as good as chance of making General as any other.


Jay
Rating
No, a Green Beret can attain zero rank and has absolutely no propensity to move through any rank structure, of any kind. Being that it is a piece of headgear, it is no better then a patrol cap.

That being said, a Special Forces officer (18A) has ZERO restriction to rank and is only limited by his motivation and choices throughout his career. Like any element though it IS restricted though MTOE requirements, as it would not make sense to have 5 Colonels in one detachment covering a small amount of teams.

Furthermore, movies are movies. They are not to be taken as fact....Just a note.


Rawbert
he figured he would die before then

You MOS or job doesn't stop you from going higher in Rank







Legal Discussion Forum

 why can world war 1 be called a war of attrition?
why was world war 1 called a war of attrition. thanks howard ...


 I leave for basic training Monday... What is Ft. Sill Oklahoma Like? ive heard it was hard...?
If your trained at Ft. Sill Please give me some INFO!...


 What is the best RATE/MOS in any branch for getting law enforcement experience?
Any branch. I'm looking into enlisting in the coast guard, and I wanted ME(Maritime Enforcement) but it appears there are 255 people on the waiting list and some have been on the list over 1.5 ...


 what's the real difference between the russian fuel air explosive bomb and the usa fuel air explosive bomb ?
...


 What's the difference between Infantry and Cavalry?
Can females be in either one? If so, which one is better or preferred? Advice once you're in either one?...


 Best overseas places for an Army 68w medic to be stationed?
Got lucky with option 19 (station of choice), i'm in the process of making my decision.

I heard Korea is the easiest to get

I'm a Single male E-4 (SPC), i really don&#...


 How physical is Active MISO "PsyOps"(37F) Special Operations?
I'm asking b/c I've heard they have to keep up with SF, Rangers and so forth, but I also know they are mostly from what I can read a "thinking" group more than physical. Also, ...


 How do I become a Army Ranger?
Im in the Army, leave for basic on 12 JUL 11, just wanted to know what I had to do or what I could do to become an Ranger?...


 What percentage of INFANTRY Marines die in Afghanistan?
My boyfriend is getting ready to deploy to Afghanistan and lately he has been REALLY worried about dying. He will be deployed through the summer months, which are supposedly the most dangerous. I ...


 Is just getting my GED O.K if I want to be a Navy SEAL then CIA SSO?
I'm 16 now and I want to go into the SEALs next year. Please don't tell me how hard it is, I have researched and I have read all there is, and I have read many books on SEALs too. And ...


 68w, combat medics.. Is it true?
I'm a 68w combat medic, i belong to the HHC company but i'm attached to a infantry company, tanker platoon... My platoon sgt and my senior medic from hhc tells me i'm not supposed to ...


 where are most 91b army active soldiers getting shipped for their first duty station?
...


 why i am not recieving payments from my husband and he is in army basic training?
...


 how do i receive military money?
i am hopefully going to get full family benefits that includes rent and food money how will my family receive this ...


 shoud my sister join the military?
shes been wanting to join the military since she was in middle school but now she is in the 10th grade and every body keeps telling her to join the air force. wat should she do?...


 Warrant Officer or PsyOps?
When I joined the Army, I had done it with the intention of going PsyOps (Spec Ops) once I reached my qualifications, but have since been told I would be a good candidate for WO (I am currently 74D). ...


 Ranger or Cav Officer?
I'm debating what I want to do when I go active after ROTC. I orginally wanted to be an Airborne Officer but my buddy talked me in to Ranger school sorta....... Anyway I'm going to 19D ...


 Are my AFQT and ASVAB scores good?
I am looking to join the Air Force but have no idea what I can do with my scores.

AFQT: 82

Standard Scores:

GS: 58
AR: 54
WK: 60
PC: 61
MK:...


 ARMY RESERVE MOS 31B?
I want to join the army reserve and become a 31B Military Police. Is this job readily available? Is this a difficult MOS to get?...


 Why were there so many friendly fires in the 1st Gulf War?
as i recall 1st gulf war has the highest casualties rates for US than Iraq and Afghanistan we have now. As i recall the Iraq and Afghanistan conflict, the US only killed 3 which is pretty small. I...




Copyright (c) 2009-2013 Wiki Law 3k Thursday, October 30, 2014 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074